Haven't seen either...but between the last two horror/thrillers I watched (When a Stranger Calls and Jeepers Creepers 2) the scarier one was Jeepers Creepers 2 although neither really scared me.
The Grudge was lame, Drag me to Hell was funny. There have been only three 电影院 that have made a lasting impression on me, and they are:
-The Descent
-The Hills Have Eyes
-Grave Encounters
There are a couple other 电影院 that were decent, but I wouldn't say they scared me, I just thought they were cool: -Splinter -Haunting in Connecticut (okay, so I jumped a lot) -Insidious (Eh) -Subject Two (horrible dialogue, but I loved it all the same) -Mirrors -P2 (That's where I got my nickname (Fork-Back) from) -Laid to Rest & Laid to Rest 2, Chrome Skull (Loved the murder scenes in that, it's one of the best slasher 电影院 of all times) -Final Destination 5 (IN 3D!) -Devil -Strangers -Quarantine