with a dad that's a murderer you have to live with him, like they do now- dan's stalking them! w/ 2 dead moms its difficult pain, but you get thru it. dan never dies!

they r all really bad but a murderer 4 a dad is worser

Well i never met my dad so i would be happy just to know him and it would matter if i hated him or if he was a murderer just to know who he is i mean its not like we have to have a relationship (at least i would have a dad) and i have a mom who cares about me but loves my brother so much more that i live with my grandma but it would be worse to lose your mom twice!!!!!!!!!!!!!

at least peyton made peace with both her moms. SPOILER ALERT - I doubt luke will suddenly make peace with dan before he becomes road kill in 518.

When you come into this world there should be at least 1 person (hopefully 2) who thinks you are the most amazing being on this planet, and that feeling of love and security and comfort should last forever. To be emotionally neglected by the person who made you and gave birth to you, to be treated like you are stupid, I imagine is the most awful feeling ever.

I'm not saying that the other two options are not horrible also, but I really believe Dan loves Nathan and Lucas, just not as much as her loves himself. And Anna and Ellie loved Peyton, and she had that peace.
I think Brooke is in the worst situation as far as parents are concerned.

especially when the person he killed is one of the most important people in your life. and then for nathan you have to struggle with whether or not you're going to let him into your sons life. i will agree with elliesowner on the fact that i do believe that dan loves nathan and lucas, i've never doubted that.

i guess the reason why i picked this one is more about the person that he killed than the actually killing part itself...i might say that brooke would have the worst situation if dan had killed someone of less importance in the life of his own children(especially) lucas. not that killing someone else isn't equally as wrong it's just that it being keith makes the whole situation that much worse.