Which version do 你 like better? 民意调查 Results - 《钢之炼金术师》

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

《钢之炼金术师》 Which version do 你 like better?

311 fans picked:

FMA 日本动漫

44%

I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.

23%

(added by Dearheart)

FMA Brotherhood

19%

(added by Eiya)

FMA 日本漫画

12%

Both, season 1 and season 2

(added by ysellemeow)

I havn't really watched the anime....

(added by starsparks)

Both!

no votes yet

(added by LeviTheAckerman)

danimlbrg posted 一年多以前

Make your pick! | next poll >>

50 comments

	tubachick picked FMA 日本漫画: I'd take the manga any day!! posted 一年多以前.

	danimlbrg picked FMA 日本漫画: they reveal more things sooner in the anime, and it also goes in a different direction from the original plot laid down in the manga. maybe i'm biased b/c i started with the manga!! I still love the show though. posted 一年多以前.

	Sango112 picked FMA 日本动漫: anime rocks posted 一年多以前.

	roxorboxorz picked FMA 日本漫画: UMMM i think the manga is like nine thousand times better, even though the anime is still freaking amazing posted 一年多以前.

	MC_Acktour picked FMA 日本漫画: havnt read the manga, though i wish i could... i need some money posted 一年多以前.

	MC_Acktour picked FMA 日本漫画: found a great sorce of scanlated manga manga is brilliant posted 一年多以前.

	zuzulala picked FMA 日本动漫: I haven't read the manga yet. I hope to one day though. So that's why i chose the anime, even though i usually prefer the manga over the anime. posted 一年多以前.

	yurikoelric picked FMA 日本漫画: i think the manga is better because it has more things than in the anime and the manga was wrote by the original author Hiromu Arakawa!!!!!! But i like the anime too its my favoriteee!!! posted 一年多以前.

	DarkChibiShadow picked FMA 日本动漫: I love love love the anime. I love the manga too but its just the anime has the whole package of awesome. The music, the animation, the story flows, I could go on and on. Both are love, but the anime is just so awesome. posted 一年多以前.

	alynn picked FMA 日本漫画: uhh...the manga and anime are both fantastic!! but i prefer the manga coz it tells more details bout the story... posted 一年多以前.

	moon_rose picked FMA 日本漫画: no dought. posted 一年多以前.

	ktlady picked FMA 日本漫画: I've changed my mind. I like the plot better, the characterizations and just everything. Of course I still adore the anime. posted 一年多以前.

	ChristiaN9 picked FMA 日本动漫: I read the Manga but it wasn't as good as the anime, the anime is better because it has Archer in it and the fight between Greed and Ed is a lot better instead of Greed getting captured by Pride which was dumb I liked how Greed was defeated by Ed. posted 一年多以前.

	Chibi-Greed-Fan picked FMA 日本漫画: The Manga is waaay better!!!~ Mainly cuz one of maii fav characters, Ling wasn't in the anime but the anime was still good!~ posted 一年多以前.

	Greedfan8D picked FMA 日本漫画: Hey you know that they're making a new FullMetal Alchemist Anime that goe by the Manga 8D It was confirmed only a few days ago when book 20 came out :33333 posted 一年多以前.

	momo_228 picked FMA 日本动漫: yayayayayayayayayayayayayayay posted 一年多以前.

	Dearheart picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: Anime vs. manga...wow. I personally think they complement each other really well. They both have their strengths and weaknesses and they're both SO good and SO different...I like 'em both! posted 一年多以前. last edited 一年多以前

	jyuuichi93 picked FMA 日本漫画: seriously the manga has AMAZING art. while the anime is still pretty good, manga all the way posted 一年多以前.

	Jehan_the_Sitar picked FMA 日本漫画: I love the anime, but I like the story in the manga better, and the manga develops my favorite characters more. posted 一年多以前.

	funkyskunk_713 picked FMA 日本动漫: i never read any of the manga, but i want to. i just dont like to read, unfortunately. but im sure that if i read it, it would grow on me. i just love fma sooooo much, and any form it was in would be amazing. posted 一年多以前.

	RinseBEE picked FMA 日本动漫: i like fma anime coz it's pretty easy to understand than manga. i always get dizzy when i read manga:p posted 一年多以前.

	SarahtheStrange picked FMA 日本动漫: I picked the anime because I usually don't read the manga especially if the anime and manga are linked. I usually read mangas that are by their selfs ya know? anyways I looooooooove this show! :) posted 一年多以前.

	pururuchan picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: The both are great! My heart goes for these two!! Although Ed in anime is waaaayy cooler than in manga ^0^' posted 一年多以前.

	ThEo_13 picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: both are great ... but i think i like the anime more posted 一年多以前.

	ling12 picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: anime there very cool and manga tells more about the story they both rock posted 一年多以前.

	MCHopnPop picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: I like both..though I think I like the Anime more :p posted 一年多以前.

	Dark-Axl picked FMA 日本漫画: manga is a lot better. posted 一年多以前.

	animefreak01 picked FMA Brotherhood: i like brother hood better posted 一年多以前.

	Hidan71 picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: Kimblee stays alive longer in the manga so thats why I like it lil bit more posted 一年多以前.

	Bebby_Kurosaki picked FMA 日本漫画: I like manga and Brotherhood^^ posted 一年多以前.

	Dionny picked FMA Brotherhood: I like the manga and the brotherhood, I choose brotherhood because I don't know about the anime... posted 一年多以前.

	laura44 picked FMA 日本动漫: I like manga but in a toss up anime would have to win :) posted 一年多以前.

	eeveelutions1 picked FMA Brotherhood: both brotherhood and the manga :I posted 一年多以前.

	NarutoCrypt picked FMA 日本动漫: i like the anime. no offense to manga fans,or peeple who picked BOTH but i think they messed up the manga,a little. its not too bad,but it isnt too much like the anime. oh..nevermind,scratch that. the real reason is,i feel more of the emotionally sad parts in the anime :) posted 一年多以前.

	MKeehl2007 picked FMA 日本动漫: Hands down, first anime posted 一年多以前.

	Animeanimal picked FMA 日本动漫: In brother hood the sense of "You can overcome anything" just depresses me.....you cant overcome God. posted 一年多以前.

	pumpkinqueen picked FMA Brotherhood: Brotherhood is the best! posted 一年多以前.

	KatrinaCrane picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: I like manga and brotherhood better but there are some things in the 2003 anime that were better then in Brotherhood and manga like... TINY MINISKIRTS! posted 一年多以前.

	noire18 picked FMA 日本动漫: I love the 2003 anime and this will never change !!!! posted 一年多以前.

	DarkWillow666 picked FMA 日本漫画: The 2003 anime series is a bad fanfiction version of the manga. I can appreciate the story concept. But all in all the 2003 anime was very...how you say...emo. Where as the MANGA and BROTHERHOOD actually followed the ACTUAL PLOT!!! There was NO cutting out characters! And that is why I will ALWAYS love the MANGA and BROTHERHOOD WAAAAAAAAAAY better then the 2003 anime. posted 一年多以前.

	Krillin18 picked FMA 日本动漫: I loved the kid as Wrath and their mom as Sloth. But Brotherhood was cool too! posted 一年多以前. last edited 一年多以前

	ANIMEPoP picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: I CAN'T BELIEVE MORE PEOPLE CHOSE THE FIRST ANIME OVER BROTHERHOOD! To be honest,,,,,,,,,,,,,I LOVE ALL 3! posted 一年多以前.

	Yaoi_FanExtreme picked FMA 日本动漫: The manga doesnt have enough EdRoy XP posted 一年多以前.

	Alchemistlover picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: All 3 are awesome posted 一年多以前.

	Okami810 picked FMA Brotherhood: i think the reason why so many voted for the first anime is, that the choice for fma brotherhood was added later. well i'm for brotherhood^^ posted 一年多以前.

	fullmetalPASTA picked FMA 日本漫画: I like the original story. My next choice would have to be brotherhood because it's similar to the manga. The first anime scared the crap outta me....I don't know why....other than the fact that I was about 6 when I watched it for the first time....:P posted 一年多以前.

	Simmeh picked FMA 日本动漫: Original FMA is the best. The manga and Bruhoooood would've been nothing without it. posted 一年多以前.

	Hina19 picked I like them both equally, pretty much; but in different ways.: I love both 2003 and Brotherhood and the manga (tough i have read only a few volumes) and the games and everything FMA! And i WANT MORE :D XD posted 一年多以前.

	LibelluleBleu picked FMA 日本漫画: FMA manga/ brotherhood First anime is meh posted 一年多以前.

	neenee22 picked FMA 日本动漫: i love this anime so much posted 一年多以前.