Tiana, definitely. Although it's a bit unfair because of course Ariel is dependent on land, she doesn't know anything about it. But Tiana is less dependent as a frog than Ariel is as a human.

Well Ariel is kinda independent on land because she does jump into the water and try to swim after the ship to stop the wedding and she does save her prince twice

^^^ Eh thats not really independence, thats more bravery or determination :)

Bravery is part of independence

^^not necessarily.

I really think they both are, but princesslullaby's comment made think that Tiana is just a tiny bit more so.

yes it is what the difference plus their both brave and independent

Well I think they are both Independent!

I agree can you explain why you chosed Ariel please

Ariel was dependent on her man to kiss her in order to become human. And she makes more mistakes that she would need help to get out of, as the saying goes, "curiosity killed the cat".

Agreed, AllegroGiocoso.

ariel is indpendent but she does everything for a man