What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

迪士尼公主 Which racial accusation do 你 think is the most unfair in The Princess and the Frog?

40 fans picked:
The only black Princess being a frog for 更多 than half of the movie
   63%
Naveen not racially identified
   23%
Tiana obliged to be this hardworking independent woman
   10%
The constant changes during production (eg. Tiana's job)
   5%
 dimitri_ posted 一年多以前
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

5 comments

user photo
dimitri_ picked Naveen not racially identified:
In advance, I'm sorry if I offend anyone, let me know if so. I know this is a controversial topic but to make it clear, I'm not saying Disney is racist but actually how they will always inevitably get accused of racism. And with the Princess and the Frog, it's obvious why it was the easiest target.

The option of Tiana having to be this independent woman is here because... they do the complete opposite of reinforcing the stereotype of black people being slugs. The movie constantly reminds us of how hardworking she is and it's so down onto other people's throats that it almost feels racist even if that wasn't their intentions at all. If that made sense.

Anyway I guess this option because whether Naveen would have been black or non-black, there would still be complaints. Definitely more so if he was non-black IMO.
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
scarletunicorn picked Naveen not racially identified:
If Naveen had been white, people would've bitched and moaned about it. "Our black princess isn't good enough to have a black prince of her own? Racist! White men with POC women couples support colonization! Racist!"

Otoh, if he had been black, other people would've also bitched about it. "Oh my god Disney supports segregation by having the black princess fall in love within her race! Racist!"
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
ajotma picked The only black Princess being a frog for 更多 than half of the movie:
I kinda wish she'd spend more time as a human.
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
UnholyNoise picked The only black Princess being a frog for 更多 than half of the movie:
^ It was huge waste of really gorgeous character design.

I once saw this really weird accusation in an academic paper that PATF is racist because Tiana is basically a "mammy" character who serves people and that Charlotte and her father aren't good, but patronizing toward Tiana by not giving her the money until she cooks for them... i was like wtffff.
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
dimitri_ picked Naveen not racially identified:
Yeah, I don't think Tia would accept the money just like that anyway. She accepted when Lottie overpaid her but that involved work.
posted 一年多以前.