I haven't seen any of Cinderella's sequels, so I don't know the situation of the dress, but with the Pink dress when I look at it I just feel sadness! I can't like it when it's so sad! Poor Cindy! Saddest moment in any of the DP films IMHO.

Okay, I'm an oddball. I think both look attractive in their destroyed forms. The pink dress was cute, but it looks a little young for her. I love the one-shoulder look of it.
The wedding dress was very plain originally in my opinion. I honestly don't know why I like it ripped. Maybe it's her hair. It looks good messy. The length is nice, and it's interesting and different.

Cinderella is just so damn gorgeous in her third movie!! Umm... I think I like the pink one because it's over one shoulder. I like that kind of look. While her wedding dress still looks plain even when ripped.

Cinderella's dresses are awesome ripped!

I actually kinda like Cinderella's ripped pink dress. I like the one-shoulder look and I think it looks better when it's ripped. However, her wedding dress still looks plain even when it's ripped.