I finally saw the 2014 Beauty and the Beast and I really loved it despite bad critical reception. Let's start with the costumes and visuals.
Costumes and Visuals
The costumes are stunning! Each of Belle's dresses are so beautiful, and blow the 2017 Belle's wardrobe right out of the water. What I loved is how the film is set in Victorian times so the normal costumes are very drab and gray but the 城堡 was set in the (16th/17?) century before the curse hit so the costumes are from that era which happens to be my 最喜爱的 era fashion-wise. Belle's ivory dress is my 最喜爱的 and she looks like a real princess with the 头巾, 头盔 on her golden locks. I especially 爱情 her sleeves her. Her 翠, 翡翠 green dress has such a breathtaking color and the same goes with her cobalt blue/teal and bright red dresses. I also 爱情 the Beast's red outfit and how it pairs well with each of Belle's costumes (white, green, blue). The 城堡 is absolutely gorgeous and I 爱情 how in the centuries since the curse, the 城堡 is not only luscious with rich splendor but also infused with nature. The mirrors in each of Belle's dreams are breathtaking as is Belle's room. My 最喜爱的 is the water tank and especially the iridescent backdrop to it (I can't figure out what it is made of though). I 爱情 the shots of the 城堡 and especially the one where Belle is standing up high and gazing at the view. Such a beautiful shot and better than anything I remember in the 2017 version, whose cinematography wasn't up to par imo. The fact that I can't remember a stunning shot in the 2017 version is testament enough. Cinderella's 2015 version had beautiful shots which I can still remember but for some reason, I can't remember much from the 2017 BATB. 更多 beautiful scenes in this film were the staircase woven in a rich tapestry of 花 and vines and the 晚餐 table. The ballroom scene was so much better executed than in the 2017 version which is really a shame because the ballroom scene is only associated with Beauty and the Beast from Disney. So 迪士尼 really should have topped their own scene 或者 at least delivered something just as good. They did that on 灰姑娘 so BATB should have been no exception. I'm glad though that this version had an amazing ballroom scene so at least one live-action BATB got it right, even if it was the wrong one imo. The far better costumes in this version definitely add to it imo.
Belle
Belle has much 更多 personality than Emma Watson's bland portrayal. I 爱情 how she likes to talk a lot which infuriates the Beast and also makes jokes and quips. Her fear is natural but I 爱情 how she is just as quick to grab a 刀 to defend herself and tells the Beast to kill her if he plans to rather than make her wait for death. Also how like Disney's Belle, she is willing to take her father's place, especially since she is 更多 responsible in this version for what happens.
The 爱情 Story and the Past Life Theory
I have to agree though that the 爱情 story is very contrived because they don't spend much time together and what time they do spend involves the Beast not 表演 very kind to her at all. The 爱情 story is practically nonexistent especially when Belle only sees his positive side in her dreams where he is with the princess. Luckily, unlike most viewers, I can see the reason why this is. I believe Belle is the reincarnation of the princess. In the original fairytale, Belle is actually the daughter of a fairy and a king so she is a princess with fairy blood. This version removes the 精灵 but swaps them out for nature gods and nymphs. 由 that logic, it makes sense that Belle is the reincarnation of the nymph because the nymph wanted to live as a human. After her death it makes sense that she would reincarnate into a full human life. Even in the original story, the merchant's youngest daughter is swapped for the princess Belle so a 邪恶力量 royal child taking on a new life as a merchant's daughter isn't anything new. There are other clues to Belle being the reincarnation of the princess. When she dreams of the prince and princess dancing, she suddenly starts to swap into the princess's role. The forest god listens to Belle when she begs him, and I can't see him doing that for anyone else, considering how vengeful he is. Especially since I doubt he would go out of his way to let some 随意 girl fall in 爱情 with the man he cursed for killing his daughter, unlike this new girl is his daughter. The golden magic is constantly following Belle and we see it emits from the 《绿箭侠》 that killed the princess, so that's another connection. The strongest one is that when the princess bleeds, her blood turns into 玫瑰 and the same happens to Belle (and this occurs to both of them when they are in the presence of the God of the Forest). Also in the original fairytale, Belle and the Beast do not meet 由 chance but their encounter and 爱情 is predestined and orchestrated 由 the fairies. This makes sense with this version too with the golden light helping Belle to see the Beast in a new light. If she dreams of her past life where she once loved the Beast, it makes sense that she would suddenly fall in 爱情 with him again. Especially, because she is warmer to the Beast everytime she sees him in real life, even if she isn't sure yet that he is the prince, but her soul recognizes him unconsciously. Without this explanation, it makes little sense that Belle would 爱情 the Beast. The Beast also seems to 爱情 Belle from the beginning and feels sadness that she will not 爱情 him back from his appearance, but that takes on new levels if it's because in her new life, the princess would not recognize the Beast as his prince. This is the only thing that explains why the Beast loves this 随意 girl he has never met before, especially since he was so devoted to the princess. So him recognizing his 迷失 love's soul in Belle explains their connection and why he loves her off the bat and also why he gives her gowns and jewels to dress her up as a princess (and she looks like a princess in that first scene in the ivory dress when they first meet and he is standing behind her). Even how they meet, because the merchant picks a rose fits with this predestined to fall in 爱情 again and be reunited because the 树 of 玫瑰 is created from the princess's death. Her dripping blood creates this majestic 树 and all the 玫瑰 are borne from her. The 玫瑰 created from the princess's blood would be the Beast's last connection to her so that explains why he is so defensive of the merchant picking a rose. In most fairy tales, they never explain why the Beast is so angry about the merchant picking a rose, especially when the Beast provides him with so many other treasures. Only in the original does it make sense, because the fairy caused the merchant to go to the Beast's 城堡 and told the Beast to hold the merchant prisoner for stealing a rose for the specific purpose of leading Belle here, so the event was orchestrated 由 higher beings. I also liked how the princess and Belle are similar in their 爱情 for the Beast but also different. The princess is 更多 subservient like a 16th/17th century princess likely would have been, but Belle never backs down from the Beast, not even upon their first meeting when she is still convinced he is going to kill/rape/eat her. She's much stronger and I think that also explains why the Beast is so annoyed 由 her at first because he isn't expecting that and is used to her 前一个 更多 docile personality. It shows a natural progression on Belle's part between her two different lives and how she has become stronger since her death/betrayal.
The Villain, the Middle, and the Climax
So I think the 爱情 story really does work if 你 consider Belle to be the reincarnation of the princess. The villain(s) didn't work for me as well. I really liked Astrid and thought that though she shares the same amount of screentime as Perducas, she is 更多 well-developed. Perducas is very generic and doesn't work like Gaston 或者 Avenant in 前一个 versions. His plotline really takes up a lot of time in the beginning and ending of the film, which is why the middle part of the film is my 最喜爱的 because it focuses completely on Belle's life in the 城堡 with Beast. I would have liked to see her explore 更多 since the original story has Belle discover libraries, gardens, painting galleries, magical monkeys and birds, and a theatre room. The 狗 didn't bother me as much as I thought they would. They appear very creepy at first but they get cuter as the film goes on although I'm not sure why the God of the Forest thought to curse them into these new forms...they don't really look that much different besides the bigger heads and huge eyes. Since the original story also had magical creatures (the monkeys and birds), I don't mind the dogs' inclusion. I think monkeys and birds would have been 更多 original though but I guess 狗 turning into monkeys/birds wouldn't make as much sense as the 狗 mutating into a different form. And 狗 fit the Beast better since they were his hunting hounds. Also I forgot to mention earlier, but the 狗 also instantly take a liking to Belle which makes sense since they liked her in her 前一个 life as the princess. The narration explains that they became Belle's best 老友记 which is odd since we never really seem them much together in the film, unless 你 take into consideration her past life. I really liked the narration although I know some people complained that they break out of the story too often, but I didn't mind that. The climax was exciting even if Perducas takes too much screentime. People complained about the giant statues being in the vein of all 最近的 CGI fairy tale films that have to have some epic battle (Alice, Snow White and the Huntsman, Jack the Giant Killer) but I didn't mind it. Statues are in the original story as well, albeit in a much lighter form, but I think the revamp to them works really well here. Once more, I wouldn't mind the climax so much if only Perducas had been better developed. He has absolutely no connection to Belle so I think I might have preferred him being a suitor like in 前一个 versions than just someone her brother owes money to. Maybe they could have combined the elements, 由 making him desire Belle and then emotionally blackmail her into marrying him because her brother owes him so much money. So he comes at the end to claim what he thinks is his (Belle and the treasures).
Belle's Siblings
I'm glad they kept her brothers from the original story as well as her sisters. Making them 3 of each is much 更多 manageable than 6 of each in the original story. People complained that her sisters were too sweet and not Belle's rivals in this version but that's not really true. They are still 更多 vain and materialistic, but they aren't the villains of the story and still retain 爱情 for Belle even if they don't see her in the same rose-tinted way that her brothers and father do. I'm glad for that because it's closer to the original story where they are jealous of her but oddly have affection for her at the same time (even if the former often outweighs the latter). I also liked how her brothers have 更多 of a role here since usually they are just around to 支持 Belle up and make her even 更多 loved than she already is, to contrast to her sisters. They become really boring characters from only having the characterization of just loving their sister, so I'm glad this version gave them their own interests and flaws.
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, I really loved this version. I know people say it's just good for the costumes and visuals and otherwise is inferior to the 迪士尼 version and the original 1946 version (which this is a remake of) but I really loved it. The main flaws aren't really flaws if 你 have read the original stories and thus understand the parallels. Most people's complaints were that Belle and the Beast didn't have a convincing 爱情 story, the gratuitous CGI characters like the statues and dogs, the sisters not being villainous enough, the inclusion of the God of the Forest and the Beast's first 爱情 in the form of the princess, and finally Perducas. All of those issues become fixed if 你 know the 来源 material except for Perducas who is also the weakest link to me. The only other complaint was I guess the narration technique but I enjoyed that. I also 爱情 how the ending shows a different type of happily ever after from both the original story and most fairy tales. I thought the ending was abrupt at first because after the Beast's transformation back into a prince, we just fast-forward to the future. I would have liked to have seen Belle and the Beast's reunion, but I suppose it wasn't necessary and probably the film is stronger for fast-forwarding through that. I 爱情 how every character gets a quick write-up at the end so we know of their fates, but especially how Belle and the prince are both happy at the end in her little cottage rather than the crumbling castle. Royal life is what tore them apart the first time so it makes sense that they would be happier together in a 更多 "provincial life." As a whole, I liked it as much as the 1991 one. Still haven't seen the 1946 version so can't compare it to that yet but hopefully I'll see that soon. Although I loved the 2017 version, I felt that was the most flawed of all these versions, and mainly because the 1991 version is so good that it simply doesn't compare. Even though the 2014 version is technically a remake of the 1946 version (and the 1946 version is considered a classic of cinema), it isn't a play-by-play remake like the 2017 one is of the 1991 one. It's very different from what limited stuff I know about the 1946 version, and I'm glad this film is completely different from that. I had completely different expectations for this film unlike the 2017 version which is probably why I enjoyed it better. However, I think that's fair because the 2017 version will obviously elicit 更多 comparisons and pretty much it was unanimous that it was good and maybe even great but not excellent like the 1991 version. So I like this 2014 version as much as the 1991 version when I want a take closer to the original fairytale and not the 迪士尼 version.
Costumes and Visuals
The costumes are stunning! Each of Belle's dresses are so beautiful, and blow the 2017 Belle's wardrobe right out of the water. What I loved is how the film is set in Victorian times so the normal costumes are very drab and gray but the 城堡 was set in the (16th/17?) century before the curse hit so the costumes are from that era which happens to be my 最喜爱的 era fashion-wise. Belle's ivory dress is my 最喜爱的 and she looks like a real princess with the 头巾, 头盔 on her golden locks. I especially 爱情 her sleeves her. Her 翠, 翡翠 green dress has such a breathtaking color and the same goes with her cobalt blue/teal and bright red dresses. I also 爱情 the Beast's red outfit and how it pairs well with each of Belle's costumes (white, green, blue). The 城堡 is absolutely gorgeous and I 爱情 how in the centuries since the curse, the 城堡 is not only luscious with rich splendor but also infused with nature. The mirrors in each of Belle's dreams are breathtaking as is Belle's room. My 最喜爱的 is the water tank and especially the iridescent backdrop to it (I can't figure out what it is made of though). I 爱情 the shots of the 城堡 and especially the one where Belle is standing up high and gazing at the view. Such a beautiful shot and better than anything I remember in the 2017 version, whose cinematography wasn't up to par imo. The fact that I can't remember a stunning shot in the 2017 version is testament enough. Cinderella's 2015 version had beautiful shots which I can still remember but for some reason, I can't remember much from the 2017 BATB. 更多 beautiful scenes in this film were the staircase woven in a rich tapestry of 花 and vines and the 晚餐 table. The ballroom scene was so much better executed than in the 2017 version which is really a shame because the ballroom scene is only associated with Beauty and the Beast from Disney. So 迪士尼 really should have topped their own scene 或者 at least delivered something just as good. They did that on 灰姑娘 so BATB should have been no exception. I'm glad though that this version had an amazing ballroom scene so at least one live-action BATB got it right, even if it was the wrong one imo. The far better costumes in this version definitely add to it imo.
Belle
Belle has much 更多 personality than Emma Watson's bland portrayal. I 爱情 how she likes to talk a lot which infuriates the Beast and also makes jokes and quips. Her fear is natural but I 爱情 how she is just as quick to grab a 刀 to defend herself and tells the Beast to kill her if he plans to rather than make her wait for death. Also how like Disney's Belle, she is willing to take her father's place, especially since she is 更多 responsible in this version for what happens.
The 爱情 Story and the Past Life Theory
I have to agree though that the 爱情 story is very contrived because they don't spend much time together and what time they do spend involves the Beast not 表演 very kind to her at all. The 爱情 story is practically nonexistent especially when Belle only sees his positive side in her dreams where he is with the princess. Luckily, unlike most viewers, I can see the reason why this is. I believe Belle is the reincarnation of the princess. In the original fairytale, Belle is actually the daughter of a fairy and a king so she is a princess with fairy blood. This version removes the 精灵 but swaps them out for nature gods and nymphs. 由 that logic, it makes sense that Belle is the reincarnation of the nymph because the nymph wanted to live as a human. After her death it makes sense that she would reincarnate into a full human life. Even in the original story, the merchant's youngest daughter is swapped for the princess Belle so a 邪恶力量 royal child taking on a new life as a merchant's daughter isn't anything new. There are other clues to Belle being the reincarnation of the princess. When she dreams of the prince and princess dancing, she suddenly starts to swap into the princess's role. The forest god listens to Belle when she begs him, and I can't see him doing that for anyone else, considering how vengeful he is. Especially since I doubt he would go out of his way to let some 随意 girl fall in 爱情 with the man he cursed for killing his daughter, unlike this new girl is his daughter. The golden magic is constantly following Belle and we see it emits from the 《绿箭侠》 that killed the princess, so that's another connection. The strongest one is that when the princess bleeds, her blood turns into 玫瑰 and the same happens to Belle (and this occurs to both of them when they are in the presence of the God of the Forest). Also in the original fairytale, Belle and the Beast do not meet 由 chance but their encounter and 爱情 is predestined and orchestrated 由 the fairies. This makes sense with this version too with the golden light helping Belle to see the Beast in a new light. If she dreams of her past life where she once loved the Beast, it makes sense that she would suddenly fall in 爱情 with him again. Especially, because she is warmer to the Beast everytime she sees him in real life, even if she isn't sure yet that he is the prince, but her soul recognizes him unconsciously. Without this explanation, it makes little sense that Belle would 爱情 the Beast. The Beast also seems to 爱情 Belle from the beginning and feels sadness that she will not 爱情 him back from his appearance, but that takes on new levels if it's because in her new life, the princess would not recognize the Beast as his prince. This is the only thing that explains why the Beast loves this 随意 girl he has never met before, especially since he was so devoted to the princess. So him recognizing his 迷失 love's soul in Belle explains their connection and why he loves her off the bat and also why he gives her gowns and jewels to dress her up as a princess (and she looks like a princess in that first scene in the ivory dress when they first meet and he is standing behind her). Even how they meet, because the merchant picks a rose fits with this predestined to fall in 爱情 again and be reunited because the 树 of 玫瑰 is created from the princess's death. Her dripping blood creates this majestic 树 and all the 玫瑰 are borne from her. The 玫瑰 created from the princess's blood would be the Beast's last connection to her so that explains why he is so defensive of the merchant picking a rose. In most fairy tales, they never explain why the Beast is so angry about the merchant picking a rose, especially when the Beast provides him with so many other treasures. Only in the original does it make sense, because the fairy caused the merchant to go to the Beast's 城堡 and told the Beast to hold the merchant prisoner for stealing a rose for the specific purpose of leading Belle here, so the event was orchestrated 由 higher beings. I also liked how the princess and Belle are similar in their 爱情 for the Beast but also different. The princess is 更多 subservient like a 16th/17th century princess likely would have been, but Belle never backs down from the Beast, not even upon their first meeting when she is still convinced he is going to kill/rape/eat her. She's much stronger and I think that also explains why the Beast is so annoyed 由 her at first because he isn't expecting that and is used to her 前一个 更多 docile personality. It shows a natural progression on Belle's part between her two different lives and how she has become stronger since her death/betrayal.
The Villain, the Middle, and the Climax
So I think the 爱情 story really does work if 你 consider Belle to be the reincarnation of the princess. The villain(s) didn't work for me as well. I really liked Astrid and thought that though she shares the same amount of screentime as Perducas, she is 更多 well-developed. Perducas is very generic and doesn't work like Gaston 或者 Avenant in 前一个 versions. His plotline really takes up a lot of time in the beginning and ending of the film, which is why the middle part of the film is my 最喜爱的 because it focuses completely on Belle's life in the 城堡 with Beast. I would have liked to see her explore 更多 since the original story has Belle discover libraries, gardens, painting galleries, magical monkeys and birds, and a theatre room. The 狗 didn't bother me as much as I thought they would. They appear very creepy at first but they get cuter as the film goes on although I'm not sure why the God of the Forest thought to curse them into these new forms...they don't really look that much different besides the bigger heads and huge eyes. Since the original story also had magical creatures (the monkeys and birds), I don't mind the dogs' inclusion. I think monkeys and birds would have been 更多 original though but I guess 狗 turning into monkeys/birds wouldn't make as much sense as the 狗 mutating into a different form. And 狗 fit the Beast better since they were his hunting hounds. Also I forgot to mention earlier, but the 狗 also instantly take a liking to Belle which makes sense since they liked her in her 前一个 life as the princess. The narration explains that they became Belle's best 老友记 which is odd since we never really seem them much together in the film, unless 你 take into consideration her past life. I really liked the narration although I know some people complained that they break out of the story too often, but I didn't mind that. The climax was exciting even if Perducas takes too much screentime. People complained about the giant statues being in the vein of all 最近的 CGI fairy tale films that have to have some epic battle (Alice, Snow White and the Huntsman, Jack the Giant Killer) but I didn't mind it. Statues are in the original story as well, albeit in a much lighter form, but I think the revamp to them works really well here. Once more, I wouldn't mind the climax so much if only Perducas had been better developed. He has absolutely no connection to Belle so I think I might have preferred him being a suitor like in 前一个 versions than just someone her brother owes money to. Maybe they could have combined the elements, 由 making him desire Belle and then emotionally blackmail her into marrying him because her brother owes him so much money. So he comes at the end to claim what he thinks is his (Belle and the treasures).
Belle's Siblings
I'm glad they kept her brothers from the original story as well as her sisters. Making them 3 of each is much 更多 manageable than 6 of each in the original story. People complained that her sisters were too sweet and not Belle's rivals in this version but that's not really true. They are still 更多 vain and materialistic, but they aren't the villains of the story and still retain 爱情 for Belle even if they don't see her in the same rose-tinted way that her brothers and father do. I'm glad for that because it's closer to the original story where they are jealous of her but oddly have affection for her at the same time (even if the former often outweighs the latter). I also liked how her brothers have 更多 of a role here since usually they are just around to 支持 Belle up and make her even 更多 loved than she already is, to contrast to her sisters. They become really boring characters from only having the characterization of just loving their sister, so I'm glad this version gave them their own interests and flaws.
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, I really loved this version. I know people say it's just good for the costumes and visuals and otherwise is inferior to the 迪士尼 version and the original 1946 version (which this is a remake of) but I really loved it. The main flaws aren't really flaws if 你 have read the original stories and thus understand the parallels. Most people's complaints were that Belle and the Beast didn't have a convincing 爱情 story, the gratuitous CGI characters like the statues and dogs, the sisters not being villainous enough, the inclusion of the God of the Forest and the Beast's first 爱情 in the form of the princess, and finally Perducas. All of those issues become fixed if 你 know the 来源 material except for Perducas who is also the weakest link to me. The only other complaint was I guess the narration technique but I enjoyed that. I also 爱情 how the ending shows a different type of happily ever after from both the original story and most fairy tales. I thought the ending was abrupt at first because after the Beast's transformation back into a prince, we just fast-forward to the future. I would have liked to have seen Belle and the Beast's reunion, but I suppose it wasn't necessary and probably the film is stronger for fast-forwarding through that. I 爱情 how every character gets a quick write-up at the end so we know of their fates, but especially how Belle and the prince are both happy at the end in her little cottage rather than the crumbling castle. Royal life is what tore them apart the first time so it makes sense that they would be happier together in a 更多 "provincial life." As a whole, I liked it as much as the 1991 one. Still haven't seen the 1946 version so can't compare it to that yet but hopefully I'll see that soon. Although I loved the 2017 version, I felt that was the most flawed of all these versions, and mainly because the 1991 version is so good that it simply doesn't compare. Even though the 2014 version is technically a remake of the 1946 version (and the 1946 version is considered a classic of cinema), it isn't a play-by-play remake like the 2017 one is of the 1991 one. It's very different from what limited stuff I know about the 1946 version, and I'm glad this film is completely different from that. I had completely different expectations for this film unlike the 2017 version which is probably why I enjoyed it better. However, I think that's fair because the 2017 version will obviously elicit 更多 comparisons and pretty much it was unanimous that it was good and maybe even great but not excellent like the 1991 version. So I like this 2014 version as much as the 1991 version when I want a take closer to the original fairytale and not the 迪士尼 version.
Idina Menzel
While I enjoy her version, she's a bit pitchy in certain parts. Although at some parts she's very emotional and I like that, because she's very ominous like Elsa and I'm glad that I like her version.
Lea Salonga
Many of 你 know that she was the 唱歌 voice of 花木兰 and Jasmine, when I heard her version. I thought that she sounds even better than Idina! I would not actually mind her voicing Elsa anyway.
But I guess that they don't want Elsa to sound like 茉莉, 茉莉花 and Mulan!
Conclusion
While both of them are good singers, I would say that Lea is the best singer out of these two!