I think many picks are better, cause a pick with 61 choices would be difficult for users to choose....

Thank you for doing this. Now whichever way it goes we know users had fair input.

For the record, the reason I think one pick is more fair is that there's no way to have equal competition on rounds, so less popular icons get through simply because they are on picks with less competition, and more popular icons are left behind because they were on picks with stronger groups. Also, the current icon has unfair advantage as rather than be included in the rounds it's automatically in the final.

Just my opinion, and thanks again willow96 for giving users a chance to have equal input. Now whichever way it goes it's fair.

Agree with mermaid-tail!

or i think the first 5 icons should make it through or something, because there is one pick where i like the first 4, whilst the other i dont like any

I agree it is not equal at all. You may have two icons in spots that people love, and a set of icons that people don't want to see.