He's got the silver stake with the magic that would kill edward and then he's got some pretty cool moves while edward could barely kill james
edward isn't a bad ass god like dimitri

edward reads minds so dimitri won't be able to surprise him

yeah but rading minds won't do anything
trust me reading minds does nothing and edwards pretty weak dimitri beat up his dad when he was 13 you know

Psh. Ed's a pansy compared to the epic Dimka. :P

lol

Dimitri knows how to fight, of course he's going to win.

Though I would love to say Dimitri. I can't. Edward would be able to read his mond, and as it says above, Dimitri wouldn't be able to surprise him.
The silver stake wouldn't do anything to Edward. He'd have to be ripped apart and burned.
So sadly, Edward would win. No matter how big of a kick ass god Dimitri is. =[[

Oh please! Deffinitely Dimitri! He's a much better fighter than Edward! And reading minds can't do anything if you're quick enough and try to think of other things.

i like them both but a stake can't pierce edward skin. dimitri would have to ripp him to pieces and burn them. Oh and lets not forget the mind reading so edward would know everything dimitri does before he does it!

dimka could beat edqueers ass haha

Don't forget Dimitri knows how to fight.. He is the best Guardian

Reading minds does nothing and Edwards is too weak to beat Dimitri

But Edward can run to save own self..

Ok I just said Dimitri cause I love him but I'm afraid to say Edward would win cause of his super vampire speed/strength.

Shit! I think Dimitri is much cooler and at least not as boring as Edward but... Twilight Vampires are stronger and faster than Strigoi and Edward's a mindreader.. and Dimitri has no wapons to kill him. :(

I was totally undecided, and wasnt sure at all lol. But i read some of the stuff here, and remembered that edward would totally win cause
A) he has super vamp strength&speed that dimitri will never have.
B) Edward can read dimka's mind before he gets a chance to make a move
C) dimitri's stake wouldn't even puncture eddie's skin! He's a twilight vamp...and therefore pretty much indestructible.

although, i hope they wouldnt be fighting to begin with...haha

he wouldnt need a stake; strigoi die w/ being burned off too... so really, he'd need to try and get edward in the fire without thinking about it too much.

for the ppl saying tht edward is super fast and its impossible for dimka to beat, remember that he's killed strigoi before (who ARE that strong and fast)

so therefore, i say dimitri!

dimitri is a hell lot cooler but edward has supernatural speed an strange AND he reads mindes. Bside Dimitri couldn't kill him... poor dimka hopefully they'll be friends when the meet.

xoxo

Don't think I like Edward, because I don't (Team Jacob!), but due to his supernatural strength + speed and his ability to trad minds he would definitely win. Just answering the question here.

1000 % dimitri :D

because Dimitri needs his arms to fight a vampire