who do like more... Edward from the book, 或者 edward from the movie

Book for sure. He's a lot more...likable in the book. The movie just doesn't 显示 Edward's personality very well. They convey him as a serious, moody, dark vampire. In the 图书 he's so much 更多 than that, he's funny (a lot of his jokes about Bella falling make me laugh out loud), very sweet, and very in 爱情 with Bella. Now I'm not dissing the movie 或者 anything, I just think that due to time restrictions and stuff they couldn't add all the small things that made all of us 爱情 Edward so much in the first place.
So book definately!

I like Edward book style... the Edward in the book has 更多 character! I think they could have gotten a better actor though. I only like Rob BECAUSE he plays Edward! <3

Edward in the book, beacuse he comes from my dream guy and he looks way hot in my mind if that makes senses

Book.

defenitly edward fro the book hes 更多 of the dream guy every girl wants to fall in 爱情 with!

Book :)

Book..

book, he's not as uptight as he is in the movie

Book.

definitely Edward from the book.. no contest :D

i 爱情 rob pattinson in the movie, hes sooo good. but i dont think anyone could ever ever live up to the edward in the book, he's just too perfect (: xx.

I Think There Both Good ,
And Rob Makes A Good Edward
So I Have to Say Both .

hes 更多 sweet in the books! the 电影院 just spoilt it for me... :L he smore funny in the books! :D

the book hes so protective...its sexy almost :P

book because he sounds 更多 better. he is 更多 likeable in the book too.

Book Edward 由 far. Like other people have said, Edward is a bit too uptight and moody in the movies.

i like both because they both 显示 sides of edward even thought he is the same person. u can picture the book edward how u want him and in the 电影院 he just comes to life the way everybody will see him outside of their minds.

okay im obsessed with edward and i 爱情 him in the movie and seeing him come to life, but i first fell in 爱情 with him in the books...You get 更多 personality and charm from him in the books, so i think that's how i prefer him.:)

Oh Wow! Robert Pattinson Plays The Part Of Edward So Well! But Stephenie Meyer Created Such An Amazing Character!

I Guess Edward From The 图书 Are Better! No Offense To Robert Pattinson-I'm A Huge Fan!-But They Just Didn't Give Him All The Touching And Sweet Lines That Edward Had In The Book!

Either Way, They're Both Amazing And My Boyfriend Is In Training To Act Like That! :)

I like both because 你 can see them in each other. And it wouldn't be Edward without Robert Pattinson! :)

edword in the movie

to tell th truth i actually like edward from the book 更多 . . . .

Definatly Edward from the book. I picture him to be way 更多 attractive.

Edward from the book <3