回答这一问题

饥饿游戏 问题

ok i have to know this: did gale kill prim? i read them all just read the discription

ok i have to know this people keep on saying tht gale killed prim i read them all and i am trying to tell them tht he didnt but peple keep putting words in my mouth so now i am confused please help me
*
READ THE DISCRIPTION FIRST thanx
katnisseverden posted 一年多以前
 katnisseverden posted 一年多以前
next question »

饥饿游戏 答案

MrsFinnick said:
He made the bombs that killed her and the children but he had no say in where they were dropped and who they would kill. Therre is no way he would ever let his bombs be the ones to kill Prim. It was President Coin who decided to drop the parachutes on all of the capitol children where Prim was trying to save them. It was Coin who killed Prim, not Gale.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
1999jacko said:
I'm sure he didn't kill her
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
thanks
katnisseverden posted 一年多以前
*
S'okay
1999jacko posted 一年多以前
pinkmalina said:
He did.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
u didnt know
katnisseverden posted 一年多以前
*
No he didn't. Read the 图书 -.- A bomb kills Prim.
TheDamnBra posted 一年多以前
flabaloobalah said:
he indirectly and accidentally killed prim.
he made the bombs that exploded and killed her, and im not sure, but someone authorized them going off 或者 something. idk.
mockingjay to me was very confusing.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
thanx
katnisseverden posted 一年多以前
LunaLayosa said:
It depends on how 你 wish to look at it.

One, yes Gale was the one who originally thought up with the idea but Beetee also helped make the bombs; so if Gale is at fault then so is he.

或者 two, President Coin who is the one who took his plans and used them to frame President Snow for her self gain(used the Gale's bombs and dropped them from blimp, hence bombing Prim). She also let Prim into the battle(so it's Coins fault).

In my opinion it was not Gale's fault because he did not intend bombing Prim (those two subjects have no connection. Plus it's his crushes sister so that really doesn't earn him any points right and he loves(as a sister) Prim.)

Also claiming Gale killed Prim is like saying the one who invented guns, bombs and missiles is the cause for all the wars, deaths and no world piece(and any deaths that occur with those weapons and wars).

Unfair right? It was only an idea to help he didn't know it would backfire.
Does this help?
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Woah. Ok, Humming bird guy= Beetee. Fedrick= Finnick. Did 你 even read the book?
MrsFinnick posted 一年多以前
*
Yes all 3 but it's been 8 months and I have read all 3 only ounce since they were the library's. Also I have read over 25 图书 some of them being Inheritance, IT 由 Stephen King, and Twilight series(my sister made me so she could buy me the Doll in the Garden 由 Mary Downing Hahn I 爱情 her books). Also if I didn't read the book how do 你 explain my answer 或者 how would I even know how to answer? Did 你 only look at the names I messed up just because I couldn't remember? I'm sorry if I can't remember anything else other than in stories 或者 worthless things I have a poor memory unless it comes to 图书 I have read others 你 could tell me something and I won't remember unless I write it over and over 或者 just on my arm. So I cna 编辑 the names and thank 你 for giving them to me but please refrain from saying things that may be rude 或者 don't make sense.
LunaLayosa posted 一年多以前
katiemac620 said:
Gale didn't kill Prim. Yes he and Beetee did 设计 the bombs but gale would never kill prim after all he kept prim and her mother fed while katniss was in the hunger games
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
elstef said:
I am not a 粉丝 of Gale, but I have to say that I do not believe that he killed Prim. I have no doubt that he didnt know what Coin was planning, and if he did he would never have gone along with it, 或者 he at least would have kept Prim out of the line of fire. I think even Katniss knows this, but at the same time she cant help associating Gale with the bomb that killed her sister.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
kealasparrow said:
No-one has thought of this...
Maybe just maybe he somehow got a bug (microphone) into District Thirteen maybe President Snow heard thier plans. No-one thought of that.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
MiNatsu_19 said:
No! Gale didn't kill Prim.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
next question »