Firestars okay but he makes thunderclan seem so weak when its strong! Bluestar was a fair leader that gave up so much for the sake of her clan!

I agree with you Stormstar!

im Stormstar dont u hear it n the clans name STORMclan, n im STORMstar

who here thinxs Firestar is a better leader then Bluestar? i no Bluestar went a little crazy but thats my favorite part of the warrior cats books! it makes the books more interesting!

I feel bad for firestar

I love firestar but I lke bluestar better

ya its like a pattern

Bluestar was more wise, and only trusted very little kittypets, rouges, and loners. but Firestar trusts every little kittypet. he needs to learn not to trust so many. i mean Daisy just sits in the nursery and does nothing useful for the Clan.

Bluestar rocxs!!!!!!! i lov the idea of a leader having a lov n another clan! n also Firestar was a good warrior n Deputy but a kittypet just cant adjust to the life a great leader.....he's 1,000,000,000 way to soft then real leaders should be!

Ihg, I just picked.

since ur like the only one that picked Firestar! that just proves that Bluestars awsome!

if u read bulestar's propacey you'll pick bulestar she give up love and lost the one's she loved . she went thourgh junk to serve her clan.

wow someone picked firestar

yea i know!

What the, I was supposed to write Moonstorm100 and Stormstar but I have no idea why I wrote Moonstar.

lolz! u must hav been thinkin that my names were Moonstorm n Stormstar bcause them combined is Moonstar! or Stormstorm! lolz!

i like Bluestar! shes awsome!

yeah lol!

i like firestar!

I chose Bluestar. Firepaw was awesome. Fireheart was okay. Firestar sucks. Bluestar rocked all around her like.

true true

my icon is firestar!

:D

i noticed

lol it's obvious that mine's feathertail!

lolz! not anymore!

-Blackkit

lol! I know I changed it 2 heaps of things!

yea! Now itz that Riley dude! Isnt he from pokemon? He looks kind of familiar..........

yes, he is & btw it's actually Sir Aaron on my icon from the 8 or something movie.

I loved Bluestar! Sometimes she could be hurtful and unfair but Firestar is not a good leader! And I am glad that Graystripe is not going to be deputy! Brambleclaw is awesome!!!

I looove bluestar!She had a tough past and gave up everything for her clan!

I've never really liked firestar...

Me either

Firestar's okay but i like Bluestar better

FIRESTAR just think of how much good Firestar has done for this clan and for Bluestar with out him thunderclan wouldn't of lived past half the rogue attack the fire the war between lion and tiger clans and leading them home drove tigerstar out of thunderclan killed scorage

As the prophecy fortold fire will save the can and it did! (19 times!)(i counted!) Firestar by far has been the most noble and kind, faor, SANE, and sweet and handsom, and loving, and adorable. Fire has saved the clans, and killed rigerstar twice, killed scourge, deferted the dark forest, led the great journey, and many more untill finally when his time comes as the story goes, brokenstar kills spottedleaf when she saves firestar and then yellowfang kills her son brokenstar and forestar then goes heartbroken into the camp and battles tigerstar and kills him but just as tigerstar fades, a lightning bolt hits the tree that fell into the hollow.and kills firestar.

So sure hes gad stupid.moments such as this one when he losses his last life to a tree. But he was destined be the forests best leader and he did live up that dstiny.