Percy Jackson & The Olympians 图书 问题
Does anyone else think the movie sucked compared to the book?
答案
|
legolasgirl21 said:
I was so disappointed with the movie. I don't think disappointed is the right word...It's 更多 like infuriated with. They made so many mistakes and changed the whole plot. They don't hunt for the pearls, the pearls were 给 to Percy. I vaguely recall Persephone actually being in the book. Yes, she was there, but she had a minimal part. It wasn't huge. Yes, Luke was a huge part of the plot but he didn't steal the bolt. That was Ares' job. Luke didn't steal it. He just tried to sabotage Percy's quest. There were also several minor details that really did annoy me. Ex. Annabeth's hair, no Mr. D., the setting of Camp Half Blood, the age of the actors etc. All in all, I was so infuriated with the movie.
|
|
|
simpleplan said:
compared to the book yes but if 你 never read the book it was pretty good
|
|
|
Sadie_Kane said:
I think, Story base is much better than the movie. Unfortunately, they cut off my 最喜爱的 parts of the book.
|
|
|
cro0010 said:
When I first saw the movie I thought it was really good then I wanted to read the book and I found that it didn't even follow the story line 或者 anything. So without the book it was good but is you've read it like I did, it wasn't so great.
|
|
|
JadedRaven15 said:
Yeah! Movie was terrible in my opinion T .T 1. No one was supposed to know who Percy's father was yet... He was supposed to find out in Capture the Flag. 2. He was offered a quest to leave camp for a lightning bolt, he didn't go on a rogue mission for his mom. But he wanted to save her as well. 3. Grover's too horney! Not awkward enough. x.x 4. Annabeth isn't blonde, and she's robotic. x.x 5. They're all too old, not supposed to be able to drive... and tons 更多 x.x
|
|
|
Poseidonsfavkid said:
你 are so right some of the things I noticed was that the gods were all in acient clothing and in the book it says the dress like normal people. And percy went alone to olympus. And only Zeus and Posiedon were in the 王座, 宝座 room plus he went to olympus because of the elevator.
|
|
|
blazeandarose said:
me. the book is very good compared to the movie. and yes, annebeth isn`t blonde. they really messed up on it big time. so im with u guys on this one.
|
|
|
Artemis037 said:
The movie was terrible compared to the book, but the movie is what wanted me to read the series because i saw the movie first. They screwed it up big time and other people have already pointed out its many flaws, but one thing that really bugged me that hasn't been 说 yet was the beginning when Percy is in the swimming pool and Grover is timing how long he can hold his breath, but shouldn't he be able to breathe underwater??? But I am really nervous for The Sea of Monsters to come out...
|
|
|
duncylovescourt said:
i actually loved the movie. i think some of the changes they made were very good, a couple of them were bad. they best change i thought they made was the age. making them 17, was a great idea. it expanding the things the characters could do. i thought the casting was excellent. Logan lerman is absolutely perfect for percy. Brandon t. jackson did a great job, he was absolutely hilarous. Alexandra Daddario did an amazing job. I actually think her brown hair 《金装律师》 annabeth much better. i loved the percy and annabeth romance scenes, they were done very well. The grover and percy friendship was also shown very well. Another change i thought was good was the pearls, how they had to find them, it makes 更多 sense than the way it was done in the book.the thing i wish they added was some information about thaila and kronos. but they can easily add that to the sea of monsters movie.
|
|
|
PJFF said:
Horrible movie
|
|
|
wierdo2 said:
The problem with the movie was it was really different from the book. If I saw the movie first I wouldve been able to enjoy it
|
|
|
Annabeth--Chase said:
It was a good movie but compared to the book, no it wasn't the best. But it didn't suck. Everyone says it sucked but it didn't. It just didn't follow the book; that doesn't make it sucky. I agree that they could have added the right scenes in, but I thought it was a good movie on its own.
|
|
|
Chrion said:
yes, but the movie still rocks.
|
|
|
T_ballack said:
yeah. In comparism to the 图书 the movie was totally off-putting. but regarding the film as a single entity, it was cool. My opinion is based on the fact that i watched the movie before the book so i have an objective perspective of the two. There where so many parts that were cut off from the movie. Maybe this was done because of the uncertainty concerning whether the movie was going to have a sequel. so now that its going to have a sequel it begs different questions. 1. How will Kronos be introduced? 2. If luke was indeed caught, what vessel will kronos be using? 3. Who will have access to the camp in other to poison (ummm....... what tree?). 4. i believe i saw a 树 in the movie but it wasn,t depicted as being important. 5. How will annabeth's relationship with percy continue to develop if it already has? 6. Will annabeth's crush on luke be totally removed? 7. Who will corral kronos army until he rises? 8. Which half-blood will try to convince other half-bloods to 加入 kronos? 9. How about CLARISSE? (Who the hell will lead the 秒 quest?(if its a quest anyway and not some mission they have to sneak out to do)). 10. And one of the main 问题 will there be a great prophecy(i ask this because; they haven't shown an oracle, the prophecy says the child of the big three to reach 16 will play a part in the raising 或者 the razing of olympus. call me crazy but i think percy in the movie already looks sixteen years so ummmm... when the prophecy happens he will be all of like what? 20. puh-lease). These and many 更多 问题 will have to be answered in the 下一个 movie
|
|
|
sydneylorae said:
It was horrible!! They could have done so much better and made so much 更多 money if they had done them right and started him off younger (like they did for harry potter) if they had just taken time and done it right! SOOO disappointing
|
|
|
zaheer_abbas123 said:
yea....i agree movie sucked compared to the book but but loved it because of percy jackson and annabeth
|
|