If you think about it though, Brooke started the crappiness (lol?). She slept with Nathan when Peyton and him were still dating.

so true......

"She slept with Nathan when Peyton and him were still dating."
Actually they did brake-up, but we all know how the relationship works with peythan..so even tho they were broken up it still wasn't right for brooke to do that!

Well peyton slept with lucas when him and brooke were dating and brooke really loved him and she did that twice and she told her that she still had feeling for lucas and kissed him when she got shot so it is mostly peyton but they were as bad as each other

if you think about it peyton was brooke's best friend imagine your best friend doing that to you twice and then tell me you don't think peyton is the crappiest friend

"Well peyton slept with lucas when him and brooke were dating and brooke really loved him and she did that twice and she told her that she still had feeling for lucas and kissed him when she got shot so it is mostly peyton but they were as bad as each other"
Ok first of all Peyt never slept with luke[Almost, but didn't]...second of all she never did sleep with him the second time[Where the hell did you hear that??]. And she only kissed luke becuase she thought she was dying!!!! And hey luke kissed back, so it's not all peyt! The telling brooke her feelings was her trying to be honest..she was trying to avoid/prevent what happen last time..brooke has said that they should always be honest with eachother and peyton was doing that..and If you're going to have a completely honest friendship/relationship you're going to always tell the truth no matter what the consequences or how hurtful it may or may not be. If peyt kept that to herself it will come out eventually and it will make brooke even more mad ! To know that she kept that in!

"if you think about it peyton was brooke's best friend imagine your best friend doing that to you twice and then tell me you don't think peyton is the crappiest friend"
Whoa..Twice?? Ok so tell me when did leyton cheat on brooke twice?? The kissing [in my opinion] was understandable becuase she thought she was gonna die..she didn't do that to hurt brooke again..she did it cuz like i said she thought she was going to die! Ok so you don't think brooke is a crappy friend to peyton as well?? Haha ok so lets re-wind to 2 years ago...Brooke slept with nate--remember?? Suree peythan broke-up, but don't they always do that?? Brooke knew that---yet she still slept with him! She also betryed peyton way b4 peyton betryed her! She punished Peyton not only for hooking up with Lucas, but she also punished Peyton for being honest with her. Brooke constantly pushed hoes over broes even after what she had done. Brooke may as well have told Peyton it's fine for me to betray you, but you had better not betray me. Brooke also needed to learn what honesty was..she gets so pissed off cuz peyt wasn't honest with her the first time, But she wasn't honest as well...She punished peyton for what she did the first time and that kinda makes Brooke a hypocrite--not sleeping with Nathan, but for punishing Peyton for betrying her when she had betrayed her in the same way. Also peyton really didn't deserve the dead mom jokes the second time..to tell u the truth i really didn't like brooke for that! Anyways moving on..to me both were crappy to eachother...but when some say peyton was the most crappy to brooke is kinda BS....i mean still....tell me again why Peyton was being a more crappy friend? She sacrified her time, her love and relationship to Lucas for Brooke, She tried helpng brucas get back together even tho it killed her inside because she had feeling for luke then, She was willing to put her feelings aside just for brooke and so what did Brooke give her in return? A slap in the face, an empty to-go box and weeks of name-calling. Am I missing something?

Og my god!!! I didn`t even bodered to read all that!!
Both have done terrible things to eachother, but they are ment to be best friends<3

peyton is such a horrible friend if i had a friend like that i would go to jail for murder, no best friend would tell their friend they have feelings for their boyfriend they would just ignore the feelings and stay away atleast that is what i would do cause i am alot like brooke and put my friends before everything

ok well that's your opinion crazednavybrat, but i would rather have a friend who is honest with me weather the truth hurts or not! I would want a open friendship where we could talk about anything & everything to eachother! Honesty is such an important part in a friendship/relationship..if my friend and i were not completely honest to eachother than i really wouldn't know what kind of friendship we have had!

brooke and payton hate each other but they still need one another

peyton iS THE CRAPPIEST FRIEND EVER SHE IS A BACK-STABBING BITCH!!!

Same i agree with the person who commented above. She is so bitchy!

i scream4dean, shut your DAMN MOUTH
i mean, if you`re gonna call a made-up character a bitch, at least get your facts straight or hmm i dunno, HAVE SOME FACTS .

WHY XXSMALLVILLEXX WHY I THOUGHT YOU WERE COOL

"peyton iS THE CRAPPIEST FRIEND EVER SHE IS A BACK-STABBING BITCH!!
Omg both have backstabb eachother!! Brooke actually was the first to do so!

"Same i agree with the person who commented above. She is so bitchy!"
LMAO..Dude have you been to the "Who's more bitchy" Poll...Brooke's winning so i think we all know who is the bitchy one=]!

hehe in every post here i must agree with Leytonfan4ever!

Lol yea i notice that Othgirl!! But that's great to know..that we share the same opinion!!

lol your so good when you make these comments leytonfan4ever :P you write like loads lmaoo! but yer at least you back up your points all people seem to say anymore is peytons a bitch or peytons the worst friend! wheres you evidece i dont see it really! what ever they come up with would be like arse backwards!! i could easily change it round to peytons point of view!!

yes peyton was involved will lucas when brooke was dating him! i agree that was wrong but lucas deserves some hating for it! peyton needed persuading before she could go through with it! now brooke is also a crappy friend cause she "was never honest with her" like peyton said! brooke was in the wrong for blanking peyton out when all peyton did was tell her how she felt! peyton was never gunna steal lucas away from brooke (she learnt her lesson)! she tried to get them back together on brookes birtday too! when peyton did finally tell lucas how she felt it was when lucas and brooke decided mutually that here was nothing left there between them! now i dont see how people still hate peyton for this and hold it against her - brookes forgiven her why cant you instead of only seeing one view point! yer your still hoping for brucas and peyton is in the way but what makes you so sure brooke would even go there again! she quoted "ive been the lindsey between you and lucas and its not a good place to be" so i dont think shell even be with him cause shell just end up gettin hurt again! leyton love each other! :P brooke is now on leytons side! cant you just be happy for leyton and not keep bitching about them?

haha ive just said you write loads leytonfan4ever and im just as bad lmaoo! :P
i couldnt helpmyself :D;)

Haha i feel the same too, sometimes i could write a page long eassy..lol

it's preety close but i'd say peyton is just worse but i agree they have both been crap to each other, but ive kinda been a bit presuaded by all leytonfan4evas comments!