Not that good as it should be. In the book I felt sorry for Dacey Mormont, Robb and the others. Where the hell are some Umbers, Manderly, Cerwin? It looks like there are only Starks, Boltons and Karstarks in the north. Jeyne Westerling shouldn´t be dead. Why to provoke Walder Frey and take Talisa to The Twins? Who would do that? This makes Robb incredibly stupid:/ Someone should release Grey Wind and let him fight, he deserved that... Maybe non-readers don´t even remember him:/
But Bran, Rickon, Jon and Osha were perfect.

Enjoyable Bran scenes... we haven't had such, since s01e01. It was awesome. Osha is great, Rickon was cute.
Maisie Williams was a disaster in this scene... All the while, she was like a wax statue with a stick up its backside. The Hound at least performed some acting when they talked about fire. Edmure was great, Roslin was cute.
Jon and Ygritte felt like a tantrum again, but Bran warging into Summer and helping him was great.
The Yunkaii fight scene was awesome too, they looked like the three musketeers. And when they went back to Daenerys and Daario appeared from behind, that was a well done scene too.
The Red Wedding... Catelyn, Robb and Lord Walder were bloody damn amazing in this episode. Absolutely awesome category. With the script willing to kill Talisa it was even logical that Robb took her along. I loved how wary Catelyn became when they closed the door and the music started, but then wariness somehow disappeared from her face, I would have preferred if she kept that up all the while Walder talked. The beginning scene, when Catelyn screamed ROBB and some bastard started stabbing Talisa in the belly I was horrified. Which is awesome, because that was point of the entire scene. The slaughter was superbly done, I was shivering to the bone. Catelyn begging for Walder to stop was great and when Bolton stabbed Robb, that was great too. Well in an 'I am horrified' way, which still means that the show did a good job. I missed the Catelyn going made moment from the end - just a scream and scratching her face. But it was really really well done, I think.
The reason why I denied 'awesome' this episode is the lack of structure, the lack of tension building and Arya/Hound (they were both terrible).

but heartbreaking!

Best episode of the season so far. Some important beats were left out but that's par for the course since the beginning of season 2. They often fail epically at the big moments so the execution (s'cuse pun) of the Red Wedding was a pleasant surprise. The tense build-up to the chillingly silent credits and everything in between were fantastic.

I was glad to see they brought Talisa along. Then I worried that she would escape. I was happy to see that she didn't. I had a bit of a giggle that they went straight for her belly when stabbing her. (Before I get yelled at again please, spare me.)

It was good to finally have some movement in Bran and Arya's stories. I felt so bad for Arya. She didn't even get to reunite with Grey Wind:(

I'm not sure if it's just me but Jojen and Meera come off as such assholes. Maybe now that they have some direction in their story they'll stop being so insufferable. I enjoyed Rickon's little bit of screen time. He was adorable but I prefer to think of him as a mysterious, slightly psychotic kid.

Hoping for a Jaime/Brienne sighting before season's end.
Didn't miss the rest of the Lannisters and other King's Landing misfits at all.

Wonder if we're gonna get to see the head-switching in the next episode... =D

Although knowing, what was to come, it traumatized me a bit...the Talisa scene with the belly, man, that was shocking! The whole Red Wedding was a scary shit, so it means, they did a fucking great job. I had goose flesh all over and nearly cried.
Brans storyline was good this time, but I was little bit disappointed with Arya/Hound.
But finally one of the best episodes in this season.

What can I say ??? Awesome and heartbreaking episode!!! One of the best episodes in season 3 !

perfect

OMFG! The episode might have been good in some way but that last scene is just the worst thing EVER!

Why is it that once you love characters they get killed off... There's a big chance I'm not watching this anymore, can't accept this... WHY WHY WHY???

I'm super pissed with the ending. And i'm pissed with Daenerys. Does she like Daario?? WTF?