BRENDA! No question. He and Kelly were miserable together.

Def U could totally C it! <3

eww kelly and him that was soo disgusting and dylan and brenda was most beautiful and romantic couple beverly hills ever had

i love brenda & dylan
are the best couple!!

It was never Kelly. Ew.

he did truly love kelly. brenda was ugly, she hated the cast on bh 90210.

Brenda was ugly?
What are you,blind?
She was the most beautiful girl on 90210!
Dylan obviously loved Brenda!

hahah Brenda ugly?? soo funny..have you seen Kelly? she look like a whore

Brendas BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!

tessomurray you meathead i wouldn't be talking, kelly looked like a rat! anyways thats not the problem, i hated DK becaus BD were meant to be & so perfect together! 90210 lost its spark after pathetic kelly clung to dylan!

Dylan told Brenda he loved her on numerous occassions. He never said it once to Kelly during the entire duration they went out.

And Brenda was the most gorgeous girl on the show.

Okay this is a hard one. Because he always went back and forth. AND STILL IS. On the new one he talks to Kelly bc apparantly she has four year old son Sammy and yet When Brenda Kelly and Ryan are all in the hallway talkn DYLAN calls BRENDA'S cellphone..Sooo good ? BUT HE DID ALWAYS COME BACK FOR KELLY. EVERYTIME HE LEFT HE CAME BACK.AND HE ALWAYS FOUGHT FOR HER 2. Dont get me wrong I HATED Kelly and Dylan all they did was fight but you got me i dont really know that one.

Okay I thought Brenda and Kelly were both gorgeous so I'm not gonna get into that, but Tessamurray you don't seem to know the difference between an actor and a character. Shannen is an actress who may have caused problems on the set, this in no way relates to Brenda, as a character and her relationship with Dylan. All Dylan and Kelly did was fight, and whenever Brenda needed something, Dylan came. If Shannen and Jason had never left the show Dylan and Brenda and Brandon and Kelly would be together.

i picked kelly cuz i hate brenda

I agree with georgiapeach91!

Dylan came back for her. <3

Because everytime she called - he came. ♥ Even at the expense of his other "relationship" with Kelly.

Brenda. He only came back to Kelly whenever Brenda would cut him loose or she wasn't available, lol. I'm pretty sure that's what happened with London too, Kelly was always the back up choice when things couldn't work smoothly with Brenda (which is why he chose her in the first place). Ever notice how Brenda was always the one that broke it off with Dylan first, never the other way around?! *LMAO* Hell, he had the perfect opportunity to dump her for Kelly when she told him about Rick that summer, yet he didn't! He entered senior year with her until Brenda broke up with him.

And FYI - alot of that media garbage on Shannen is a 'smear job.' True, Shannen had some issues at the time, but it was NOT all her. The cast was jealous of her, one of the producers even admitted it (they didn't want to let her go). In fact, they never fired her, Shannen went to Aaron Spelling and asked to leave but she was afraid he'd sue her if she did. But he agreed to let her go from her contract so that she could work things out in her personal life. I heard Jennie was just as bad and that long after Shannen was gone, she was still acting jealous and continued to cause trouble for the other actresses who came to the set (like Tiffany, Hilary, etc.).

I just want to say one thing about Dylan always coming back for Kelly. Brenda wasn't on the show when any of that was happening. If she were still there, Dylan wouldn't have constantly gone after Kelly.

Ok look. Even if I was a huge Brenda and Dylan fan (which im not) I would say Kelly. It so obvious. He fought so hard for her and he didnt even care about Brenda. She's a controlling bitch. He came back to Beverly Hills for Kelly!! DDDDDDUUUHHHH He left Brenda...for Kelly! Theyre amazing and its obvious who he loved more

to me it's obvious that it was brenda he truly loved.

Brenda was a whore and such a bitch to me I hated her and I didnt care if she was with Dylan because Kelly was meant for Brandon not Dylan. All dylan wanted was sex from Kelly and Brenda. He was a jerk and Brenda went with him because she was a bitch.

^^ Brenda was a bitch to YOU?! The fuck? Dylan waited a long time to have sex with Brenda. It wasn't just about sex to him. Brenda went out with him because she was a bitch?

Kellytaylorfan : Logic is your friend. Use is more often.

I am the BIGGEST Brandon/Kelly fan there is, those two just belong together, which is why I loved anyone that would keep Dylan away from Kelly. I agree with 90210er though, it just depends where in the series you're at for who he loved. First it was Bren, then Kelly, then Toni, then Bren, then Kelly. Here's how I always see everything, Brenda loved Dylan who loved Kelly who loved Brandon who loved Kelly. Once again, I do not like DK, actually I HATE them, but I think Dylan really did love Kelly.

Brenda all the way. Dylan and Kelly was just pure lust

Even after they broke up, he always turned to Brenda
when he really needed support. He always sided
with Brenda when Kelly was being a bitch
(which was most of the time).
There was an amazing chemistry
between Brenda and Dylan.
With Kelly it always seemd forced.

Dylan and Brenda had the most intense relationship, and Brenda acted more like his mother than his girlfriend. With Kelly it was sweet and lighthearted, so I'm going with Kelly.