回答这一问题

《行尸走肉》 问题

问题 about Carl: Right 或者 wrong?

What would 你 have done if 你 had been in Carl's position?

Would 你 have shot the guy... 或者 left him to supposedly hand over his gun when he was clearly ordered to drop it?

Do 你 think what Carl did was right 或者 wrong?

What would 你 have done differently and do 你 think it would be as 安全 and effective as Carl's decision?

Do 你 think the guy's intentions were good 或者 bad?

 Simmeh posted 一年多以前
next question »

《行尸走肉》 答案

bouncybunny3 said:
I think his [Jody's] intentions were good. I think he was just scared.
But after all that had happened- a domino effect- Carl wanted to protect his group. He only had moments to make that call. In a world like that trusting is very difficult.

So, I think Carl was right.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Cool. I'm glad that 你 see Carl wasn't in the wrong. Also... is Jody a character from the comics, 'cause I never heard of his name until now. Well, I never even saw that guy until this episode.
Simmeh posted 一年多以前
carlspudding said:
Rick probably wouldn't have done that, and I think that Carl did the right thing! Last time Rick was in a room with governor and had the chance to kill him, he didn't and got several people killed. So Carl thought that 由 killing that one kid on the spot could have saved the group from getting themselves into 更多 trouble. The kids intentions were probably good, but he is in a better place now and we can forgive and forget...
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
next question »