回答这一问题

Sherlock 问题

I'm confuse with Irene Adler sexuality, which side she prefer?

I'm little bit confuse with this, when John 说 " ..for the record out anyone out there still cares, I'm not actually gay" Irene answered "well, I am"
I thought she prefer girls but after that she and sherlock have this crazy chemistry with each other, she 说 to sherlock she playing him, but I'm not sure if that the truth, do 你 think she lied to john? 或者 she actually telling sherlock the truth?is there any confirmation about this? Help?
 rere14 posted 一年多以前
next question »

Sherlock  最佳答案

cocoa020 said:
What I think Irene was trying to get across was that John isn't gay, true, and Irene is gay, but that doesn't mean they both don't romantically 爱情 Sherlock. So when John was saying, "For those who still care, I am not gay!" Irene responded with, " Well, I am!" Saying it doesn't mean 你 can't still 爱情 Sherlock.

Soo, what I'm trying to say is that Irene is a lesbian who happens to 爱情 Sherlock. He's her exception like he's John's exception.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
next question »

答案

bri-marie said:
Why does she have to prefer either? Bisexuality is a thing that exists. And why does she have to be gay or straight or bisexual? There are other sexualities out there.

Also, a gay person can be attracted to a person of the opposite sex. It's not common (it's actually really rare), but it can happen.

And who says she's attracted to Sherlock in a romantic/sexual way at all? 或者 that he's attracted to her a romantic/sexual way? There can be chemistry without any romance. Sherlock (and Ben) has great chemistry with Watson (and Martin), but it's obvious they aren't attracted to each other.

I don't think Moffat 或者 Gattiss (or Pulver) have 给 us anything about her sexuality beyond what's been 说 in the show. And, realistically, they probably won't.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
That's a great point, her character really is amazing, 你 can't know for sure with her, she make us keep on guessing, maybe that's why sherlock really interest with her, thank 你 for answering ;)
rere14 posted 一年多以前
*
She COULD be bisexual, the 照片 were of her with a FEMALE from the royal family. But she is attracted to Sherlock, because he notes that her pulse quickens and her pupils dilate.
LittleLottie posted 一年多以前
Hkiara said:
I think in that scene with John and Irene she tried to tell that she doesn't believe that he's straight.
"I'm not actually gay."
And she 答案 "Well, I am" to make it a scene were both of them is lying. Like she's is saying "You're as much straight as I'm gay, which means not at all."
That's just a theory :P
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
This is very astute. I like this idea.
collie123 posted 一年多以前
*
An entertaining thought, and most amusing to the Johnlock fans, but unlikely. John is clearly straight and genuinely annoyed that everyone thinks otherwise. IMHO, that's what makes it so funny.
VixeyC posted 一年多以前
VixeyC said:
She is definitely gay.

At the very beginning, they tell 你 that she has sexual 照片 of her and a FEMALE royal member. (If they are reflecting the original cannon, it is an even deeper relationship than just a client.)

The 下一个 line after saying to John "well I am" is "look at us both". Meaning, that even though John is straight he loves Sherlock, and even though she is gay, she also loves Sherlock.

It is possible she is Bisexual, as she keeps saying "I know what he likes." when asked how she knows things, but that doesn't necessarily mean sex, men can have many private interests 或者 weird fetishes that are not exactly sex.

So if she is bisexual 或者 homo-flexible it is left entirely ambiguous. (bisexual meaning attracted to both genders, homo-flexible meaning attracted to same gender but willing to participate in sexual activities with both/either genders.) I'm inclined to think she is homo-flexible because being a professional dominatrix she probably caters to both genders, but it is all business and her personal orientation is gay that's why she says "well I am" when John says he's not gay.

I think this episode eloquently demonstrates the difference between 爱情 and sexual attraction, how they are two different things, and how they can exist independently of each other.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
Natalie_Singer said:
Well I think Irene prefer herself))) Seriosly, she meet a man 或者 a woman and she thinks "OK I can profit from working with him, so I will be with him". Who is her "new big love" - it doesn't matter at all. She is a versatile srecialist))))
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Lol, that crossed my mind, that attitude kinda awesome, isn't it? thank 你 for answering :)
rere14 posted 一年多以前
9gagirl said:
She likes whips and chains and anything they hurt.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
Raizon said:
I think that what she's saying is that she is homosexual, but that it doesn't change the fact that she loves Sherlock, any 更多 than Watson being straight changes his feelings for Sherlock.

select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Didn't see your post cause it's hard to read on 潮流粉丝俱乐部 on my ipod. I 发布 below an pretty much restated what 你 said, but elaborated just want to give credit where it has been earned.
cocoa020 posted 一年多以前
jcaslcgaiwd said:
I believe she likes a little bit. Whatever she can get.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
Fandomlover7906 said:
Irene Adler is bisexual. She does not have a preference. She has a girlfriend but she is in 爱情 with Sherlock.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
Malavika22 said:
Irene is gay but she is attracted to sherlock so maybe bisexual?

select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
next question »