Do 你 think if Snape didnt get caught up with the Dark Arts his friendship with Lilly would have gone further?

I don't think the real problem were the Dark Arts, as every other science (they were a science in the wizards' world) they have a good and a bad side as well! But the matter really is HOW these arts are used, let's not forget that Snape's knowledge in this ''subject'' saved Dumbledore's life, gave him one 更多 year...And the fact is: at that time Severus and mostly his 老友记 didn't use them in a proper way, plus all that misunderstanding between Slytherin & Gryffindor... I'd say it was a ''question of circumstances'', and it's not to blame the Dark Arts on that!

Yeah i do :P haha that would be funny if Snape was Harry's dad! :O wow that would be kool in one of the films!

Yes. I think that he could have had better relationship with Lily than James, because they have known each other for so many years. Lily disliked James until the last class of Hogwarts, which I think is Snape's fault because if he hadn't joined Death Eaters and liked Voldemort's ideas, he would have become her boyfriend someday. And James, well... I think that Lily fell in 爱情 with him because she felt hurt after Snape's words, how he offended her just because she was trying to protect him from Potter and Sirius. James was adoring her for so many years and he wanted to be with her. Snape too, but he didn't have courage to tell her that. I think that's one of the reasons why he had 迷失 her.

Yes I think the friendship could have even gone farther. I personally think that they could have been much 更多 than friends.

I think yes, but it wasn't only Dark Arts, but I think he was attrated 由 them fot the problems his parents had, all the situation he was passing by; his parents fighting, james trying to 日期 Lily, the 爱情 of his life, and much 更多 things. But I would loved if that friendship continued, and well they were like so cute toguether. Bad thing he didn't had the courage to tell Lily that he loved her. But that friendship had to be sacred and inseparable.

i think so. cause it was snape calling lily "mudblood" that made her break things off. but if he had stayed innocent maybe something 更多 could mave happened.

*nudge nudge, suggestive eyebrow raise*

YES!!!!!!! he chose a way that a relationship with blily would have gotten her KILLED! a muggle born and a death-eater would NOT have gone down well AT ALL!!!!!!!!!!