迪士尼公主 Round 4: Which DP Film is the WEAKEST (Elimination 由 Comments)

This question is now closed
22 fans picked:
睡美人
睡美人
   41%
魔发奇缘
魔发奇缘
   23%
《白雪公主与七个小矮人》
《白雪公主与七个小矮人》
   14%
美女与野兽
美女与野兽
   14%
灰姑娘
灰姑娘
   5%
阿拉丁
阿拉丁
   5%
小美人鱼
小美人鱼
no votes yet
花木兰
花木兰
no votes yet
 Jayden-G posted 一年多以前
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

10 comments

user photo
睡美人
Jayden-G picked 睡美人:
11. Brave
10. Pocahontas
9. The Princess and the Frog

Just because it is a classic does not mean that it should not get criticism for its flaws.

This movie does have some plot-holes and loopholes, but not even including that, it has a thin story with thin characters, many filler scenes and scenes that are too long/short. A lot is not explained, and there is a lot that could have used more development and explaining. This film lacks in every single aspect compared to the remaining films. I think this is one of Walt Disney's weaker works to be honest.
posted 一年多以前.
last edited 一年多以前
 
user photo
魔发奇缘
AudreyFreak picked 魔发奇缘:
said why before.
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
睡美人
princecatcher93 picked 睡美人:
I'm feel classic biasness about this film. Plot-holes, loopholes, doesn't give you enough time to get to know the main character let alone them as a couple. The main people are sidekicks and the whole drinking song with the fathers? Come on Disney! It's like the crab killing song from The Little Mermaid.
This, TLM or BatB are next on my list.
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
阿拉丁
rhythmicmagic picked 阿拉丁:
Classic bias? Since when has that existed?
Plot holes that are worse than those in PatF (IMO) and a ton of things that are contrived. There's a ton of humor that comes out of no where. There are also a ton of problems with things in Jasmine and Aladdin's relationship, such as the fact that they don't pay attention to what the other says and it ends up unintentionally portraying Jasmine as REALLY materialistic. Almost the entire plot is based on the fact that Aladdin can't marry Jasmine because he isn't a prince, but in the end it's solved by the king just changing the law. If that's all that needed to happen, why did we have the last hour of the movie? Why didn't Genie making him a prince last the whole movie, did he just disguise him as a prince- in which case, Genie didn't grant a wish. Why did it take Jafar seeing the lamp to recognize Aladdin when he'd sought him out, put him in prison, pretended to be in prison with him, and sent him into the cave of wonders? Why didn't Jasmine take the lamp and wish Aladdin into being a prince again before Aladdin wished Genie free? All of the dialog of the characters and the pop culture references have already dated the film horribly- heck, I can't understand a lot of the jokes in this movie. I regret voting out PatF last round.
posted 一年多以前.
last edited 一年多以前
 
user photo
睡美人
Jayden-G picked 睡美人:
^ I think what princecatcher93 meant by classic bias is that the movies in that era get excused for the flaws and issues in it because it is a classic, and it was older, so it gets written off a lot on Fanpop.
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
灰姑娘
dclairmont picked 灰姑娘:
I just can't get into this movie....none of the characters really spark my interest :c
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
睡美人
Popcornfan picked 睡美人:
I think Cinderella is quite weak, but since it's so iconic, it should get further in the countdown. Sleeping Beauty, while personally one of my favorites, it´s not so popular.
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
睡美人
tiffany88 picked 睡美人:
Still this one...
posted 一年多以前.
 
user photo
Snow White and the Seven...
Swanpride picked 《白雪公主与七个小矮人》:
I get more the impression that the Classics are getting more critic than they deserve, because people expects them to be more than the more modern movies, not understanding that those movies didn't even try to create a broadway musical about a Princess going on adventure. They are more about the Fairy Tales like they were.
Nevertheless, I think Snow White is the weakest movie of the one left, simply because it's the one with the most filler scenes. And I mean real filler Scenes, which don't add anything to the plot at all. I think this movie could be half as long and we wouldn't miss anything.
(I really don't get the current hate towards Sleeping Beauty).
Though to the credit of ALL the classics: They aged very, very well, something you really can't say of Movies like Aladdin.
posted 一年多以前.
last edited 一年多以前
 
user photo
睡美人
JNTA1234 picked 睡美人:
Again I like better than Tangled, but I must admit this film is weaker. It's soooo slowpaced and quite honestly it's the only "weak" film left in my opinion.
posted 一年多以前.