When Stormfur went with Brooke back to Thunderclan, you could tell he wanted to stay. But retarded old Brooke got in the way agian, she was homesick and Stormfur felt sorry for her. Stormfur would of really loved to stay with his dad, Graystripe and his best friend, Brambleclaw. Brooke was the one who dragged poor Stormfur into this. So she sould respect his feelings too.

i disagree with u, stormfur loves brook and thats all that matters

that was just pathetic i agree ENTIRELY with fadingecho's reasoning!

No, He shouldnt have left the clans cause once your a clan cat, it sticks to you and you start to miss it like FadinEcho posted, he wanted to be there meaning that he should have stayed there where he belongs, cause it is what he was born for?

I think that he should have just stayed no matter, what i mean in the next book if you havent read it yet, and i dont want to give it away, but something bad happens within the Tribe of Rushing Waters, and StoneTeller no longer belives for some things, and StormFur would have been better off staying in the clans and never having to deal with the other cats up there, with border patrols in the mountains, and with other predators that could kill him!!

this one was hard for me... but Stormfur made the right choice according to himself. Hes happy with Brooke. I think thats all that should matter, right? Fadingechoes thats just ur opinion. I agree with Ninano1998. IT WAS STORMFRS FRIKIN CHOICE.

I think what he did was right. If it where me, I would have stayed with the clan! But wait, I haven't lost my dad, mom, and sister!

Stormfur WANTED to leave because he could never come back to the Clan he had always belonged in!

And Feathertail's grave is there!

But frathertail was loyal 2 riverclan till the day she died. That's the reason she died. And stormfur must respect that. SHE DIED 4 THE CLANS!!!!!!

FadinEhoes was right, Brook's fault all the way!