i think that if she chooses edward like she did in eclipse, there will be pain for not being with jake, but she already went through not being with edward and it almost killed her, and at the end of elcipse she had pain but it wasnt as bad. like she said when edward asked her,
" are you sure you made the right choice, i have never seen you in so much pain"
and she says "I have known worse pain"
does that mean, the worse pain was when edward left her

I think if she chooses JAcob and not Edward it would be too much pain for her becuz as much as she lovez Jacob she still lovez Edward more and it would hurt her even more then when Edward left her in New Moon becuz he left her for like 4 month
Imagine all her life and it would be a pain that will scar her 4 life

omgg good point!

if edward died that would be heartbreaking

yes.. i think if Edward died it would be even worst for her because she suffered not being able to be good enough for him.. which was not tru... but knowing that he's not real anymore...& i think she said that the only thing that kept her alive was that she knew he existed ...or sumthing like that.

She will not pick Jake over Edward!! If edward died she would be heartbroken! So would i =)

If edward died she would probaly go with jacob, so 'edward dieing' and bella 'choosing jacob and not being with edward' are kind of the same thing

of course she'd be sooo sad if edward died!!!

Well, if she choses Jacob or Edward, she loses what she might have had with the other one but still has the one she chooses. And they are both great. However, if Edward were to die...

Yeah, hello! Edward dying is definitly the worst possible thing that could happen to Bella. It would be just lke him leaving her again, only a thousand times worse! Good question.

WHOA WHOA WHOA. Edward better not die. It's worse than him leaving her like in the 2nd book. Even though he left her and she was in so much pain for 4 months, at least she knew he was still alive. Can you imagine if he actually died? That's hell, WITHOUT her angel. And hell without her angel, is BAD.

If BOTH of them died she would be lost in this world and wouldn't have a reason to live! =(

then she'd HAVE to be with Mike Newton!!!!hahahaha!!! or she'd die!!!

That's both of the people she couldn't live without dying!!! That would be really sad and if that happened I would totally like cry my self dry!!! I hope it doesn't though!!=)

I think that, as impossible as it is, Edward dieing would, quite literally, kill her.

Choosing Jacob and not being with Edward certainly is not the worse Bella could go through. I could think of at least five other things that would kill her.

This would hurt her the most.

Choosing Jacob wouldn't hurt her. She's said time and time again, Jacob makes her happy. especially in her darkest time away from Edward.

She wouldn't be able to live though something like that. If Edward were to die, it wouldn't be long before she died too.

it would kill her if he died
and if it didnt she would kill herself

I think...if Edward died [oh god just thinking that breaks my heart] she would kill herself...O.O I think

well since i know Edward is not will be died,so i pick this.