hayden christensen can't act his way out of a paper bag. he would be a terrible edward

I love Hayden, but Rob is gonna be the prefect Edward!!!!!!!

NO
FUCK THAT
HAYDEN
WOW HE WOULD BE AN AMAZING EDWARD, HES GOT SOMETHIN TO HIM THAT HE JUST SHOWS SO MUCH PASSION AND LOVE AND LIKE EMOTION INTO A LOVE STORY

Ar first i was totally against Rob... but now i've seen some pictures of him and i started to think maybe... but im not totally for him yet, but i probably will be after the movie. (i personally would think Gaspard, but his accent might get in the way)

OH!! Tebbla...how could you? lol Robert will do a fine job! Hayden is FINE though lol

none of these guys are edward. remember the discription of him! Robert Pattinson does not fit it! Do not forget he is very strong and physicly fit. This actor looks weak! I see a skinny guy with somewhat definition. But not EDWARD! There is got to be better. But, I understand filming has started. Not in the area book said. But! in Portland. Hello what happen to Washington?

the other dude is kinda creepy looking

lol cept he looks like he just woke up lol

Hayden is an amzing actor, he would be a better edward than rob, rob can't even act, where as hayden he is one of my favorite actors and he's is not my favorite just because of he's looks, he really can act.

robert is the absolute perfect edward! hayden would have wrecked it!

Duh.

PERRRRRRRRFFFFECTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT. He reminds me of Edward i agree with heyther0689

NEITHER!!! i just dont imagine edward as any of them!! I have this picture of edward in my head and its not them!!

as much as i love hayden.. robert is too perfect!!! for edward that is.

:O/ I actually think Hayden would be amazing. but i really don't care anymore. Robert is Edward, and he's gonna do amazing

after seeing Jumper...yeah

I'm sorry i go Hayden all the way, i was actually upset when they picked Robert because i didn't like him at first but now he is growing n me, but i still think Hayden would have been able to do a better job but ooh well

Rob is THE perfect edward!! And not hayden christensen..

Hayden played Darth Vader. He already played a popular character, it's someone elses turn.

Not that I have anything against Rob...

*Robot voice* "Danger, danger. My name is Anakin. My shitty acting is ruining saga."

That really is all I can think now when I see Hayden Christensen.

Hayden Christensen is the worst. actor. ever.
Robert Pattinson is amazing.

i just love rob hes great

but he can take a bad photo some times -xx-

He's got that edge to him.

Though Hayden looks better in his picture....lol, you could have chosen a better pic of Rob! :( (lol, it's ok)

RP always.

He played Cedric, the hot guy, its not wrong for RP to play as edward, the even hotterrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr guy :)

i liike hayden but rob is the perfect edward

hayden looks more like the edward i imagined

Although Hayden would've made such a great Edward :)