who played phantom better? 民意调查 Results - 歌剧魅影

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

歌剧魅影 Who Played Phantom Better?

55 fans picked:

butler (don't know 1st name)

44%

Ramin Karimloo

36%

michael crawford

13%

lon chanley (the man of 1000 faces)

scotie3 posted 一年多以前

Make your pick! | next poll >>

17 comments

	animagic0927 picked butler (don't know 1st name): its gerard butler is his name posted 一年多以前.

	scotie3 picked Ramin Karimloo: oh posted 一年多以前.

	GarlicWreath said: Lon was right Lerouxian mix of terror and pathos, not seen Ramin, Gerik and Michael - despite their shallow, laughably excused evilness - were also deliciously dark, tragically tortured and gorgeously poetic (thanks to music of ALW and lyricist Hart). Hm... Can´t choose! posted 一年多以前.

	Danea picked butler (don't know 1st name): So Much Raw Sexuality.... Gawd! posted 一年多以前.

	Solefitjar27 picked butler (don't know 1st name): i was going to tell u his first name too.. then i looked at the first comment, said crap, and erased everything btw, if u wanted to find the name, you could've just looked around the spot or asked it in Answers... posted 一年多以前.

	lovemymusicals picked butler (don't know 1st name): Gerard Butler has made a fantastic version of the Phantom you have to remember that some of the listed Phantoms were on stage and some on Screen!!! posted 一年多以前.

	emmysuperfan1 picked Ramin Karimloo: watch the phantom of the opera 25th anniversary at Royal Albert Hall, Ramin is amazing! I'm a bigger fan of the stage show, but i love the movie 2!:P posted 一年多以前.

	jay1119 picked butler (don't know 1st name): butler is a great singer and actor posted 一年多以前.

	DamianLUVR picked butler (don't know 1st name): awww man.... dont make me choose between Michael Crawford and Gerard Butler.... they are both utterly amazing for this role... but i suppose i like Gerard a little bit more. posted 一年多以前.

	mitsukunisan picked Ramin Karimloo: I completely and totally agree with emmysuperfan1 =) posted 一年多以前.

	missliss picked Ramin Karimloo: i chose ramin cause im a big fan of his i loved his performance in Les Misérables posted 一年多以前.

	phantommusic picked butler (don't know 1st name): Gerard! I'm more of a Raoul fan myself, but I still love Gerry as Phantom. Beautiful voice! posted 一年多以前.

	Masked127 picked michael crawford: Hard choice.. I absolutely LOVE Ramin Karimloo he was my first Phantom.. but the only thing that comes between them is THAT laugh . . . Ramin's doesn't quite meet Michael's there posted 一年多以前.

	fansfunsz picked butler (don't know 1st name): all posted 一年多以前.

	LLCoyote picked Ramin Karimloo: His acting seems to encompass everything I ever thought about the Phantom when reading the novel for the first time. For some reason Erik has always had a child like quality among all of his darkness along with a certain pitiful nature that always made me feel for him. Somehow, when I watch Ramin (especially in the new dvd where I see him up close and just watch his face) I see almost everything I ever imagined the Phantom to be. I'm sorry but Gerard Butler didn't have the voice for the part. Was it a great voice? Yes. Did it make an impact at certain times? Totally. But it was a bit ordinary and sometimes sinister where I always saw the Phantom's voice to be beautiful and hypnotic. So I've gotta go with Ramin. <3333 posted 一年多以前.

	Tetske20 picked butler (don't know 1st name): Gerard Butler, Michael Crawford and Ramin Karimloo are all three my favorite Phantom's. posted 一年多以前.

	ICONicgirl7 picked Ramin Karimloo: Ramin owns this part! posted 一年多以前.

发表你的评论

歌剧魅影

歌剧魅影 Who Played Phantom Better?

17 comments

登录或者加入潮流粉丝俱乐部来发表你的评论

歌剧魅影 more polls