Yeah he was just trying to help

yes and no....i understand that he was trying 2 help but in a way i think he should have known that dean wouldn't have went along with the immortality thing...which was the reason he tricked him....not really sure how 2 answer this one so i just went with no

they should have been hunting him to kill him NOT to learn his secret - he should have known Dean would never become something like that - but i get that Sam was desperate and just trying to help his big bro =(

It actually took me a while to decide this one. I said yes coz if Sammy had said it might be immortal Doc then Dean might have refused to go and more innocent people might have died. Also Sammy is getting desperate, he needs his big brother and he saw a way to buy some time for them to find a loop hole or to find out who the contract holding demon is and kill them.
In Sammy's eyes it probably wasn't right but it was they only way to help Dean.

No, definitely not. Sam's become sickening and scary and sometimes down right unlikable. Whatever Dean broght back, it's NOT the Sammy we all know and love. That doctor was evil and he killed people to stay alive. It's disgusting that Sam would even consider that.

i think it was right i mean sam is tryin to help dean after all he did say he didnt want to go to hell so i mean hes tryin to look out for his bro is that so wrong i didnt think so

Nope! I was with Dean in this one!It was creepy and sick!
I agree with duckey94.