THE Sisko of course ;)

Sisko, because he was such a real, genuine character. Not to knock TNG, but the characters all so two dimensional. Sisko was someone we can all relate to. He had heroic qualities, but was also flawed. But then, that was the primary difference between DS9 and TNG.

I saw Star Trek TNG first, I saw Deep Space Nine last. Somehow, I feel like I'll never like Sisko better than Picard just because I saw the other one when I was little.

Sisco goes a little to ape-shit near the end but that aside it's a close call.

Sisko's such a bad-ass! Love him!

I looove the actor behind Sisko (Avery Brooks) and the character is more down to earth but Picard is just more exciting ; this "lack" is another point why DS9 has so much flare (and why it's so good).

I love the Sisko, but Picard will always be my #1 Trek captain. <3 I think the TNG characters are very three-dimensional as well; they all have strengths and faults, and I find them extremely relatable.

The Sisko