I really like them both, but after getting to know her better in the manga, I slightly prefer Ymir.

^ Me too.

I don't like either of them.

But Ymir's developed into a better character as well, in the manga.

I am starting to like Annie more now.

Annie is a terrible person for killing so many people. Even if her father had told her to hate humans, she should've realized that humans are innocent and came up with an opinion of her own. I think she's a cool character with lots of depth but her actions are TERRIBLE and she made pretty much all the wrong choices.

As for Ymir, I love her so much!! her devotion to protect Christa is just astounding, gotta love those girlfriends.

Favorite vs 3rd favorite. Annie is love.

My beautiful girl <333