No i don't think Ronan Parke should have won, as the scottish man was a LOT better then the child in my opinion. I believe Ronan would have cracked under the pressure as i thought he was too sensitive and impressionable. I think he should wait a few years, get a little older and wiser before trying again, that way he may be able to win. But i'm glad the scottish dude won, his voice was purely amazing. So strong, powerful and passionate.