I think I would've done the same thing

*LOVE IT* Poor Marion didn't do anything wrong, and now Roland has his mom back. I mean he's only 4 years old or something. Although Marion didn't seem to want to go back at first, so that's why I picked this.

If you were in her place could you honestly say that you could just run off and leave an innocent person to die? I SURE AS HECK COULDN'T!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'm a HARDCORE Outlaw Queen shipper but I feel like Emma is getting too much hate because while it was a dumb choice she's not stupid or a worthy of hate because she has a heart. Regina has every right to be mad, I wouldn't blame her if she stayed mad at Emma for most of season 4, at long as she doesn't go back to being evil, but I feel like her fans hating Emma is a bit too harsh. I mean Regina has killed innocent people to kill Snow White for something she did when she was just a child. Emma is responsible for it but she's not the only one and needs to face some consequences and fix her mess but I think the hate she's getting needs to be dialed down.

Emma shouldn't be getting any hate at all, that's ridiculous. How was she supposed to know that bringing back Marian would ruin Regina's love life?

Some prior posts; I mean, now that my disappointment subsided I feel like I could give Emma more leeway, it's Rumps that has me mad still. I just don't like the situation. I'm more so annoyed...disappointed? With Emma. It's like I really want to keep liking her, but the writers are really making that tough. I don't hate Emma, I hate where the writers are taking her. I hope they fix it in season 4.

As of Emma saving a life. Her intentions were good, her heart in the right place. But she damn well knew that making even the very slightest change could ruin a lot of things. And then she goes and meddles with something as huge as life and death. That's something I believe no one should toy with. Marian was supposed to die, and it's just balance upsetting to change that.

Long story short; I feel like they have been ruining Emma's character since season 2. She just hasn't been herself. I can't put my finger on why, but she's just not being Emma. I understand what she did, she had good intent. It was essentially the right thing to do. However, meddling with such a huge aspect of time is not the brightest no matter who's doing the meddling. And my natural Regina bias has set the alarm bells ringing.

Okay Marian didn't do anything wrong i love OQ but hell Regina was in the wrong completely she was the one who wanted to execute people. I'm sick of fans hating good people for doing good things and the anti heroes being made like their saints.

She was just trying to save a life, she had no idea who she was! I WILL NOT TOLERATE ANY HATE TOWARDS EMMA FOR DOING THIS...It was the right thing to do. And, besides, true love isn't easy! I still have hope for OQ :D

@Alchemist I don't think Regina was actually going to successfully execute her. Didn't Robin say she died because of his thieving? Yeah Regina tried to execute her but I feel as though she would have escaped Emma or no Emma. I can't speak for everyone but I don't hate Emma. I simply hate the situation. And the anti-heros are not made into saints; over on tumblr there's a whole blog dedicated to Regina hate--they claim that in the 3A finale she was just giving Emma&Henry new memories to separate her from the Charmings again. They say a whole lot of crap like that. And she and Hook are still being called rapists. They are not being called saints.

I would have done the same thing; I just feel horrible for Regina. I feel like it was the right thing to do.

Zan- I understand there hated by the fandom also don't get me wrong you know Regina, Rumple and Hook are my three favorite characters I love them and defend them but sometimes there fans can't accept that they've done inhumane things (mostly Regina and Rumple) i get you I hate the situation also but the hate towards Emma is annoying me I think Regina herself will forgive her more easily than the fans will. Also ignoring every good thing they've done in my opinion is just as bad as ignoring the bad I can't say with confidence about Regina but I can say nothing I have seen tells me Hook is a rapist he flirts like crazy but that's it the worst thing he does is get a girl drunk and that's her choice remember he kept asking Emma if she was okay and if was having second thoughts? Even his evil pirate self wouldn't violently force a girl into anything I don't think.

I am glad Marian is back.

I know you like Gina and Hook and all of them. I could see where you're coming from. I mean I love Gina, but slaughtering a whole village wasn't the most moral action she's taken. I get what you're saying with the whole too much justifying. But I think there are two extremes not just one. I honestly don't hate Emma, but I don't like her either. She's kind of off to the side for me. Just waiting to see what happens.

I just don´t like emma before she bring marion.. i simply don´t like her and now i think that she is really dumb, you don´t bring someone from the past without consecuences...

I actually really liked Emma this episode! Her emotional side is beautiful when it shows! Even though I feel terrible for Gina, the arrival of Marian is sure for some interesting scenes between Regina/Emma, Regina/Robin & Regina/Marion!

I would probably do the same if I was in her situation.

It is a fault because even if she did the right thing (saving someone) ,she's been told mutliple times that's she sould not to change anything from the past but seriously the hate she gets it's ridiculous & pointless ,I'm just sad for my baby Regina </3

@zylice, same!:)
It was her fault (she should have taken Hook's warnings more seriously) but at the same time it's understandable. I probably would have done the same myself.

^^ I feel like the hate most characters have been getting from the fandom is crazy.

Yeah, Robin and Neal are the main ones. Like CS shippers saying they're glad Neal is dead and now their ship is canon. I actually saw someone the other day making fun of a SF shipper just because CS is canon now. But other than ships, no character gets hate for being a character. Well George and Greg maybe, but nobody else really. Rumple has been getting some hate recently after what he did to Zelena.

^ I actually really like Neal, and I hated that he died. (and I ship CS) There's always some shippers who get really rude about characters who "get in the way" of their ship. For example: people saying they want to kill Marion because she gets in the way of Outlaw Queen. I'm an OQ shipper but that seems a little extreme to me...

There's really no other way for Outlaw Queen to happen unless Marian dies because if she's alive that means she and Robin are still married

Yeah same ^^

There's always divorce? I just feel like Marion is getting a lot of hate that she doesn't really deserve. And I don't think she deserves to die.

I personally don't hate her. Not yet. I'm waiting to see how her character is.

She safe her from her death, so now Regina's special someone is someone else since Emma change the past, i wonder who it is?

She didn't change who Regina's true love is? She didn't go that far back to be able to do that.

she is very fault

Honestly, I don't "hate" Emma for it, but then again, I can't believe she would be willing to mess up someone's future like that. Sure, Marian being alive doesn't mess with the Charmings' lives but it might have messed up other lives and Emma didn't think about that.
Also, my heart just broke for Regina at the end of the final episode. :'(

Emma didn't know that she was Robin's wife so...? ^

It's not her fault!! It's no ones fault. Why would I hate her for saving someone's life. In fact if my feelings have changed about anyone it Regina for killing the wife of the man she now loves in the first place.

I agree ^^^ Emma's heart was in the right place, she wanted to save an innocent, but I was SOOO MAD at her after that episode. I still like her and all, but she should have known better than to mess with the past...

for one letting innocent people die is totally not cool and i understand saving her. but also she was messing with time which she should know is dangerous. i mean she just snapped a twig and that changed a lot and didn't consider the consequences of saving a whole human being who was supposed to die. understandable but ultimately i do have to agree with Regina that her family totally ignores that there might be consequences for their actions.

This.