Her and Ariel are my favorite characters. But I still love Emma.

BY FAR! I LOVE Emma and I'm neutral about Alice. For some reason I feel like if I had to choose between like or dislike that I'd dislike Alice. If she does anything to Anastasia I'm going to dislike her and maybe even hate her.

By far i love Emma so much

Definitely.

Alice is awesome, but Emma is fantastic. I'm not wild about how Sophie Lowe portrays her. I liked Mia Wasikowska in the 2010 film better.

Same Mia rocked

Mia and her film were awesome! Sophie isn't that good in my opinion.

I like Emma fine, but Alice a little bit more I think. :)

Emma all the way.. :P Though I really prefer Knave over Alice. And I agree with what misse1000 said.

I do love that their protagonists are so strong and independent though.

I like Alice, too.

Srsly?Emma Swan FTW!!!!

I think she has way more personality, interest and strength. I also think that she's prettier and I like the actress better:) Emma is my third fave <3 (Hook might be catching up on her, though) I honestly find Alice a little boring. Agree with you guys, Mia did a fabulous job:)

By far!