well the people that say that are soooo wrong. it is 150% James but i guess they think that because snape loved her and in the beginning 你 can tell she liked him before she met james. go to
link and in the beginning of snapes memories as shown 你 will see his adventures with lily as children. 你 will see that in their first 年 at hogwarts lily and james met in gryffindor and eventually got married and snape and lily were separated when snape was put in slytherin. 你 will see that people must think this because of the 爱情 connection between lily and snape, anthough james is totally harry's father, not snape. Also, later in the memories, 你 will see that snape sends his patronus which is a doe (hmmm....) and dumbledore says "after all this time?" and snape replies, "always." hmm.... as 你 can see, lily, james, harry, and snape's patronuses are all types of deer. so when 你 hear this 你 aren't really sure what this is supposed to mean and 你 really don't get much help from the 图书 either. Some people think that to have the same patronus as another person 你 must be blood-related somehow... which is possible but not really mentioned in the series, 图书 或者 movies...anyway, i think some people might get the idea from this misleading conversation 或者 idea. 由 the way, this scene is in DH (part 2) when snape dies and harry takes the tears to the pensieve and 查看 snape's memories. Also, something interesting: snapes patronus is not a 麈, 牡鹿 it is a doe, same as lily's. This makes me believe that if 你 爱情 someone truly, your patronus is the same as theirs- it depends on what kind of situation. So because snape's patronus is Lily's, i guess people who believe the blood-related patronus thing must think that he is related to harry because harry is related to lily...Therefore, i think the reason why dumbledore says "after all this time?" is because he just figured out that because his patronus is a doe then he is in 爱情 wth lily. and snape probably says "always." because he is saying that he has always loved lily.