回答这一问题

哈利·波特 问题

Book glitch 或者 memory glitch? PoA - Time-turner.

In PoA, Dumbledore tells Hermione "three turns should do it" and tells her it's nearly midnight. So, 由 my reckoning... They should re-start time at around 9ish.

So why do they end up at 7:30???

If there's something wrong with my logic 或者 memory, please tell me... I'm actually confusing myself with this now, it's driving me nuts!
 SiriusSeverus posted 一年多以前
next question »

哈利·波特 答案

freshfunkpride said:
Who says one turn equals exactly one hour?
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Uhm... The ever-trusted and relied upon Wikipedia... And I'll admit, a rather large amount of presumption...
SiriusSeverus posted 一年多以前
emiehs96 said:
Well Hermione did say that it took them exactly 3 hours back. And I'm not sure what Dumbledore 说 what time it was. I would look it up in the book,but I don't have it. Maybe that's something 你 could ask J.K. Rowling.


**Edit**

OK! So I got the answer. Me and my friend discussed it this morning. So Dumbledore says it's NEARLY midnight,meaning that it could be 11:30 and if the Time Turner takes them bac three hours,then they will end up at 7:30(or somewhere near there). YAY! I solved it:D
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
11.30 minus 3 hours is 8.30 not 7.30, an 小时 is quite a big difference. Also i doubt there was a half 小时 before it was midnight as when they are returning, they hear the chiming of the clock as its turning twelve, so there is at least an 小时 and a half thats is unaccounted for
lauracullen66 posted 一年多以前
*
i 说 somewhere near there. And when the clock rings,it doesn't mean that it was midnight. It could mean that it was another time. I don't know,that's my opionion.
emiehs96 posted 一年多以前
bri-marie said:
Both. You've gotten the movie and the 图书 mixed up, my dear.

In the book, Dumbledore says it's "five 分钟 to midnight. Three turns should do it." (393) Then, as they are listening to themselves go down the front steps and off to Hagrid's, Hermione asks, "why did he tell us to go back three hours?." (396). It never tells the actual time, they just keep saying, "three hours."

However in the movie, it's near midnight when Dumbledore locks them in (and when they return) and Hermione specifically says, "7:30. Where were we at 7:30?" It was a glitch (since the directors didn't realize that three turns does indeed equal three hours), but not a book glitch.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
So there we go :) thanks!
SiriusSeverus posted 一年多以前
*
No problem :)
bri-marie posted 一年多以前
next question »