Do 你 think the 爱情 that Severus had for Lily is stronger than the one Edward has for Bella? 民意调查 Results - 哈利·波特与暮光之城

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

哈利·波特与暮光之城 Do 你 think the 爱情 that Severus had for Lily is stronger than the one Edward has for Bella?

176 fans picked:

Yes

80%

14%

I'm undecided

burgundyeyes posted 一年多以前

Make your pick! | next poll >>

42 comments

	renrae picked No: The love I feel for my friends is stronger than what Edward and Bella feel for eachother. posted 一年多以前.

	makintosh picked Yes: For sure! posted 一年多以前.

	nati30 picked Yes: Severus turned on Voldemort because he killed lilly, voldemort can read minds and would be able to tell if snape wasn't really on his side and was spying for dumbledore and would oviously kill him if he found he wasn't on his side, so severus put his life at risk for many years for lilly, even though she had a husband and was already dead. when edward does something like that, i might change my choice. posted 一年多以前. last edited 一年多以前

	lilyZ picked Yes: Agree with nati30! posted 一年多以前.

	weaslyismyking picked Yes: Puh-lease, Edward was aroused by Bella's "mysteriousness": He couldn't read her mind and she smelt positively delicious. Bella went out with him because he was gorgeous and she was desperate enough to do so. If Edward was ugly and he could read Bella's mind like everybody else's, I doubt they'd give each other a second glance. They're entire "love" is based on lust. posted 一年多以前. last edited 一年多以前

	mebanana17 picked No: These 2 can't B apart!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! posted 一年多以前.

	Lackson4ever85 picked Yes: Yes because Snape love Lily from they was kids:D posted 一年多以前.

	samjhart picked Yes: I have to agree with nati30. Snape loves Lily so much that he was willing to protect Harry just because he was Lily's son and lets not forget the whole Patronus deal :) posted 一年多以前.

	walker93 picked Yes: Nati30 said it all. posted 一年多以前.

	ilovecreed13 picked Yes: Nati30 did say it all posted 一年多以前.

	duckey94 picked Yes: I'll admit that I still hate Snape, even if he is a good guy. But what he felt for Lily was the real deal, man. I mean I just bawled at some points for him. In Twilight, Bella never noted anything about Eddy that wasn't physical beauty. posted 一年多以前.

	vampiressJazz picked Yes: yes thats why he hates harry so much posted 一年多以前.

	kellysimona picked Yes: it's amazing how he risks his life for lily, even after she's dead! when she dies, he doesn't go to italy to off himself, he protects what lily left behind! one of the few things in this world that make me cry! posted 一年多以前.

	XDRoseLuvsHP picked Yes: Honestly? I'd say Cho and Harry's relationship is stronger than Bella and Edwards. posted 一年多以前.

	Mrs-Grint picked Yes: Of course, it's ever so sad. Poor Snape, but then, if Lily didn't marry James, there would be no Harry. But it always wrenches my heart. In Deathly Hallows when Voldemort orders Nagini to bite Snape, then he leaves, Harry runs for him, and Snape asks Harry to look at him "Look...at...me" So Snape can look into Lily's eyes one more time before he dies, it's bittersweet. posted 一年多以前. last edited 一年多以前

	LadyLilith picked Yes: You all said it. To compare what Severus felt for Lily to what Edward actually feels for Bella (NOTHING OTHER THAN BLOODLUST), it's simply outrageous. Disgusting. God I hate Twilight and the majority of its fans. Stupid stupid stupid. posted 一年多以前.

	ToyletGnome picked Yes: Severus loves Lily so much he sacrifices his own life to protect her son, even though she had the child with a man he hated. He risked his own life for years by spying on the most powerful dark wizard of all time, who would've killed him without batting an eyelid, because he loved her so much. If that's not true love, shoot me now. posted 一年多以前.

	sleazy_weasley picked Yes: Obviously. No need to explain. posted 一年多以前.

	iBaseCheergirl picked Yes: I think I don't have to explain it again. I've discribed the nature of Severus' love a couple of times already on this spot :D ALWAYS! posted 一年多以前.

	LoopyLuna96 picked Yes: Every time I think about Snape and Lily, I feel like crying. Snape put his life in danger for years for Lily. He saved Harry, even though he was his worst enemy's son, because he was Lily's son. It's true love! posted 一年多以前. last edited 一年多以前

	Angel-Trix picked Yes: Snape was willing to risk his life for Harry, Lily's son,, even though Harry's father was the one who took most of the happiness away from his childhood Now THAT is love Edward is abusive and a terrible boyfriend. He won't let Bella live her life. But Bella WAS an idiot for liking him in the first place! posted 一年多以前.

	SVUlover911 picked Yes: Snape/Lily have the saddest love story I've ever heard. I love Snape the anti-hero. posted 一年多以前.

	IzzyOzera picked Yes: i cried so much when snape said he still loved Lily even though she had died years ago :'( posted 一年多以前.

	ravenclawgirl5 picked Yes: Derrrr. posted 一年多以前.

	PotterForever picked Yes: Yes. No further explanation needed. posted 一年多以前.

	bri-marie picked Yes: He changed everything about him self, risked everything, put himself through mental torture on, practically, a daily basis, and socially ostracized himself to make sure she didn't die in vain. Yeah, I think that's a wee bit stronger than "I love you so much that I'm not going to kill you." posted 一年多以前.

	KatiiCullen94 picked I'm undecided: Love cannot be measured or weighted. Plus their are Fictional characters, their Love is made up. posted 一年多以前.

	Wotcher_Harry picked Yes: he dedicated his entire life to keeping her son safe, and helping to bring Voldemort down. He risked everything, let people think the very worst of him, Now THAT is true love posted 一年多以前.

	TeamGalacticFan picked Yes: His love for her was much much stronger! posted 一年多以前.

	cassie-1-2-3 picked No: I think that's a horrible question to ask. posted 一年多以前.

	souflizzle317 said: I don't feel like officially choosing but it's a definite yes. Allow me to explain: (for the purposes of not overusing my quotation marks to say things like Edward's "love" for Bella, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt that Edward and Bella genuinely love each other) If Bella left Edward and had a baby with Jacob, Edward would never do anything for that child. He would probably move his family far away so he would never have to see Bella again. And if somehow he ended up in Snape's position, I can't imagine him doing so much to protect the child of Jacob's. Severus risked death for Lily and consequently Harry hundreds, maybe thousands, of times over seventeen years by earning and keeping Voldemort's trust, even while working against the Death Eaters. Years after she was dead, he was still desperately in love with her ("After all this time?" "Always" and "Look...at...me...") He hated James for bullying him and then winning over the girl he loved, but he protected James' son all of his life because he was Lily's son too. Most men might not intentionally harm the child of their loved one and another man, but most wouldn't go so far as to protect said child. Severus would do anything for Lily, even if she wasn't around to see his actions. And the montage of Snape's memories in DH Part 2, where Alan Rickman showcases his incredible acting abilities of heartbreaking love has more deep and beautiful love than all of Robert Pattinson's attempts of love in the Twilight movies. posted 一年多以前.

	FalconAnimagus picked Yes: Severus died to save the so lily had with his enemy. Bella would die trying to kill the child if she were put in the same circumstances. Besides, I 'love' my worst enemy more than bella 'loves' Edward. They have a lust relationship. posted 一年多以前.

	ClaireVoyant picked Yes: YES! DAMMIT! it's even stronger than Romeo and Juliet! it's harder to live AND suffer for your loved one AND STILL CAPABLE OF LOVING HER DEARLY AFTER HER DEATH! than die (or comatose) and be done with it! posted 一年多以前.

	FalconAnimagus picked Yes: Yesyesyesyesyes!!! posted 一年多以前.

	cunha27 picked No: Maybe not. Snape's devotion and love for Lily was wrapped up with guilt. They were never a couple and Lily never reciprocated his feelings for her (feelings that we only guessed he had since he never actually admitted to having romantic feelings for Lily) so was he devoted to Lily's memory because she had been his only true friend and he felt guilty for causing her death or because he was in love with her? I mean Snape's devotion to Lily's memory and Sirius' to James seem to be about the same. I could see Sirius doing everything Snape did because James had been his friend, yet I don't think Sirius was in love with James. Also if he truly loved Lily then surely, to Snape, Lily's wish to protect Harry would have superseded Dumbledore's plant for Harry to sacrifice himself to defeat Voldemort. If he'd been protecting Harry for Lily and done everything because he wanted to honor Lily's sacrifice, then why did he go along with Dumbledore's plan to as he put it "to keep him alive so that he can die at the right time"? posted 一年多以前.

	TriaRose picked Yes: I'm pretty sure that your Patronus matching another person's is a sure sign that you're in love with them, and definitely not in the same way that Sirius was friends with James. And it was made incredibly obvious that Snape was in love with Lily. If you couldn't see that, go reread "The Prince's Tale." In my opinion, it's a much better love story than all four books of Twilight. Because Snape knew that there are some things more important than that. He recognized that sometimes one has to die for the good of many, even if that someone is the last thing you have of the one you love. At least Snape's love for Lily went beyond looks, unlike Bella and Edward's. posted 一年多以前.

	cunha27 picked No: No, Snape's patronus did not match Lily's. James's Patronus matched Lily's. The stag is the does' match. Snape's patronus mimicked Lily's. I'm sure JK wrote it so for a good reason. That to me denotes more a sense fixation than love. It was I believe JK's way of showing the difference between James and Snape's feelings towards Lily. Snape is my all time favourite character so rest assured that I've read "The Princes Tale" enough times to pick the little clues left by Rowling. My interpretation is obviously different from yours, but I can see how you've reached your opinion. I simply disagree with you for the reasons I've stated above. Snape didn't keep Harry alive because he was the last thing of Lily alive. He did it so that Lily's sacrifice was not in vain. So to then turn around and help Dumbledore means he basically chose the cause over Lily. As to recognising that sometimes one has to die for the good of many, we start entering into murky waters. If it is your own choice made freely as in the case of Dumbledore and Snape then fine, but that wasn't what Dumbledore had proposed. Dumbledore essentially took away Harry's chance to make his own choices. posted 一年多以前.

	alexisn10 picked Yes: In the middle. Snape truly loved Lily and sacrificed himself to save her child (which obviously holds a part of her) yet Edward has done the same for Bella several times. Lily and Bella are on the same page, too (in a way). Lily saw Snape as a friend and didn't love him back. In my opinion, Bella saw Edward on for his looks and was just in love with the idea of love. In both cases, I can see a lot of obsession. posted 一年多以前.

	TriaRose picked Yes: Yes, Lily and James were soul mates (the Patronus is a projection of one's soul) and Snape's became a doe because of his love for Lily. I think that Snape did love Lily, truly and deeply, but maybe it was in a different way than James did. And personally, I feel that Harry would have chosen to die even if Dumbledore had offered him a choice (I don't know what the other option would have been, besides "die or everyone else will"). Through his emotions and thoughts on his walk to the forest, I think he knew that he was doing the right thing. And yes, I can see where you got your opinion too and I see where you're coming from. You make a good point! I just disagree. So let's agree to disagree. :D posted 一年多以前.

	julesie12 picked Yes: Severus knew Lily practically his whole life. She was his only friend. He loved her even though she didn't love him in the same way. posted 一年多以前.

	RonGetYourWand picked Yes: In the words of Snape; "Obviously," posted 一年多以前.

	spellpatronus picked Yes: Snape protected his childhood nemesis' child for his love for Lily, even his patronus shows it. posted 一年多以前.