哈利·波特与暮光之城 Club
加入
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
posted by metman5715
After viewing a decent number of articles, questions, and 论坛 on this site, I realize that all who say that these two series cannot be compared are right. The two are different genres and therefore are difficult to compare.

I will say that I am a die-hard, never give in Harry Potter 粉丝 who would not be caught dead 阅读 Twilight. But that is my opinion. It seems to me that Twilight 粉丝 are never 给 the chance to fully explain the reasons they prefer Twilight because the Harry Potter 粉丝 base does not allow them to do so. We have become so used to dealing with the hardcore 粉丝 that we fail to remember that not all Twilight 粉丝 are like this. I have no issue with a good, healthy 辩论 in which the participants of both sides behave maturely and avoid demeaning the other side, but all I ask is that we do not immediately put down the other side for liking a different series.

We as Harry Potter 粉丝 are entitled to our opinions that we prefer Harry Potter over Twilight, and the Twilight 粉丝 are entitled to their opinion of the opposite. I have seen battles like this with other things as well. In one instance, I saw a battle between tow versions of a musical that were 30 years apart. I will say here what I 说 there: due to the different styles, one can say a version is PREFERABLE, but not necessarily better.

What we find better in our opinions are just those: opinions. Nothing more. I do not see why we 粉丝 cannot put these differences aside, agree to disagree, and just 移动 on with life. I see no reason why the Harry Potter 粉丝 base and the Twilight 粉丝 cannot just live together and keep their opinions. No one can change a persons mind but that person. So I say we drop the all out battle and 移动 on. If 你 want to have a healthy debate, 或者 a joking battle with 老友记 of the opposite 粉丝 base, I say go for it. But forget the full throttle battle in which nothing happens but 粉丝 trashing the opposite series. That is how I feel. Please 评论 and tell me what 你 think. This is my first article, but do not hold back for that reason.

P.S. I apologize for any grammatical errors I may have made. I do the best I can with it. It is one of my biggest problems when I write essays.
Well, lately I have come across a variation of the following sentence a lot:

"Harry Potter is better than Twilight because Twilight gives a lot of bad messages"

I won't deny the message 给 由 Twilight is an awful one and easy to spot, but Harry Potter also has its share of bad messages, and whats worse is that it is conceived between lines. There's an extense 辩论 among psychologist on the validity of subliminal messages, but that I will not discuss.
Following I will list, in my opinion, the (bad) messages each book gives.

Let's begin with the easier one, Twilight:

1. Looks tell a lot about...
continue reading...
added by crazychocolate
added by Brysis
added by TeVaerua
Source: http://phishfillet.tumblr.com/post/254112150/lockedheart-followandreblog-via
added by DivyaHarry
Source: www.google.com
added by BellaCullen96
Source: Uncyclopedia
added by crazychocolate
added by crazychocolate
added by crazychocolate
added by MiraclexBlazer
added by Brysis
added by Brysis
added by Brysis
added by Brysis
added by crazychocolate
added by crazychocolate
added by crazychocolate
Okay so I've come to realize how all of this is just pointless. People seem to only compare Twilight and Harry Potter because the two are popular. That is a main reason why those two are being compared now. Now to me I have really found this to be pointless. People are comparing a romantic fiction story to a 幻想 fiction story.

Now when I realized this is when a 评论 was made 由 a user who goes 由 the name: justmandi23
on the topic "1000 reasons why twilight is better than harry potter" So what she wrote just made me realize what I did. I 发布 like a lot of reasons in the topic, "1000...
continue reading...