回答这一问题

哈利·波特与暮光之城 问题

What would have happened if Neville had used a normal sword to chop Nagini's head off?

*
It would have been Neville's last 移动 ever. :) 哈哈
emilykuru posted 一年多以前
*
I mean obviously it would still cut it's head off. So would it still stay alive without it's head 或者 would the it die and have Voldemort's soul fragment fly off to attach itself to something else?
cunha27 posted 一年多以前
 cunha27 posted 一年多以前
next question »

哈利·波特与暮光之城 答案

Nevermore_ said:
probably not much seeing as Nagini was a horcrux.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Yes, but how much would he have hurt her? Would he have been able to hurt her enough to put her out of commission?
cunha27 posted 一年多以前
*
I wouldn't think so. Think about how the 项链 reacted to other magic, it only jumped away 或者 flew a few feet in the air. I assume the same would happen for Nagini.
Nevermore_ posted 一年多以前
*
Yes but the 项链 wasn't a living thing
cunha27 posted 一年多以前
graystone said:
Well, Nagini does happen to be a horcrux. So, I doubt that Nagini would be hurt if normal sword had been used.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
But Harry was also a horcrux and he got hurt all the time. Eg broken arm in quiddich, scar on hand 由 Umbrige's quill, almost drowned in lake, cut himself, etc,etc
cunha27 posted 一年多以前
*
Hurt, not dead. Hence the term the boy who lived.
lukita posted 一年多以前
*
@ limits: I know that, that's why I asked the question. We know that normal sharp objects can damage a living horcrux as evidenced 由 Harry cutting his hand on a mirror. So my 问题 was what would happen to Nagini had Neville cut it's head off with a normal sword. Woul the head grow back?
cunha27 posted 一年多以前
Spottedpool said:
the same thing that wold happen if he used avada kadavra... nothing
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
I thought the avada curse worked which is why it killed the horcrux in Harry when Voldemort cast it on Harry in the Forbidden Forest
cunha27 posted 一年多以前
*
good point, but maybe thats because harry was human.
Spottedpool posted 一年多以前
*
Not so much human as living. 你 can destroy a horcrux 由 causing it damage that can not be 可逆 由 magic. I assumed the avada can not break 或者 cause physical damage to an inanimate object and that's why it wouldn't work on a not living horcrux.
cunha27 posted 一年多以前
Parseltongue said:
I think the sword would break.. cause Voldemort would have made some protection charms over Nagini which could only be broken 由 Gryffindor's sword 或者 a Basilisk's fang...
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Hmm, if Voldemort put a charm stopping sharp things from cutting 或者 piercing through Naggini, then the sword of Griffindor would not have had any effect on Nagini as it's the basilisk poison imbued in the sword that makes it deadly to the horcrux. If the sword can't pierce the skin then the poison in the sword wouldn't be able to enter the snake's body. We know that mere contact with a weapon imbued with the poison is not enough to kill anyone as Hermione handled a basilisk fng and did not die from coming in contact with it.
cunha27 posted 一年多以前
Book-Freak said:
It wouldn't have broken through Nagini's shields, and then Neville would have been killed 由 Voldemort.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
next question »