回答这一问题

哈利·波特与暮光之城 问题

Which form of torture is stronger; Jane's power 或者 Bellatrix's Cruciatus Curse? And how long do 你 think they can endure each other's power? Who will last longer?

 Helena-B-Carter posted 一年多以前
next question »

哈利·波特与暮光之城 答案

zanhar1 said:
Bellatrix's cruciatus curse; Jane's power only makes people think they are in pain, really it's all a mental thing. Whereas crucio actually does cause real, physical pain.

Therefor I say Bellatrix would last longer; Bellatrix isn't really getting hurt she just thinks she is and feels like she is, but Jane actually is getting hurt so her body would probably give out faster. Not to mention Bellatrix's mental state is so screwed up it's hard to say if Jane's powers would even work on her. If Bella can use her shield I'm pretty sure Bellatrix can block the pain out too. To add another point; Bellatrix is an occlumer, she can block out the pain since Jane's power only affects the mind.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Crucio is only mental also
cassie-1-2-3 posted 一年多以前
*
But her pain is an illusion, it never happened, the person just thinks it did. WHere as crucio is not an illusion, it actually did happen and the person wasn't just imagining the pain.
zanhar1 posted 一年多以前
*
Most likely, none of them would win 或者 they'd both kill 或者 seriously injure each other. I just think if one 或者 the other had to win it is 更多 likely that Bellatrix would. In all honestly I think they are 更多 likely to team up then anything.
zanhar1 posted 一年多以前
cassie-1-2-3 said:
We have no way orf knowing this 或者 even making an educated guess. Both powers are pretty much identical. No one here has experienced either infliction.
Anyone who says Bellatrix is only doing so because they like her.
Anyone who says Jane is only doing so because they like her.


I don't know who would last longer, but I do think Jane would inflict it longer. Simply because she can last longer just standing there doing nothing.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
AmonTheFallen said:
I would say that this 问题 is actually multiple ones.
1) Which is stronger?
Harry described CC as pain beyond anything he ever felt that was like if his 识骨寻踪 were burning and making him want to die.
Jane makes every cell of your body on fire.
So I think the pain is +- the same as both are that your body is simply burning.
2) How long will they endure.
Jane I would say for extreme periods before going mad and maybe even after that.
Bellatrix would use at some point legimency (before Jane even attacked) and analized the attack of Jane and would find the illusion and how it doesnt work on Bella 天鹅 and would immedietly apply Occlumercy which would block the pain alogether and surround himself with Fryendfire so Jane cant attack her 或者 wont attack her physically and after that simply kill Jane.
3) Who would last longer?
Bellatrix for sure as she actually has a way to prevent the pain and wouldnt be harmed but Jane has no defence.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
Book-Freak said:
I personally think the Cruciatus Curse would be stronger, because in one of the Harry Potter books, it mentions that after the curse had been lifted, Harry was left with aching pains all over his body, which implies that the Cruciatus Curse has a physical effect on the body, whilst Jane's powers are purely mental.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Are 你 saying mental pain can't leave physical effects? That's not even true in the real world
cassie-1-2-3 posted 一年多以前
*
Doesn't the Cruciatus curse bring about physical and mental pain?
zanhar1 posted 一年多以前
*
That's what I was thinking
zanhar1 posted 一年多以前
cunha27 said:
Interesting question. I thought Bellatrix's Crutiatus would have been worse, but after checking out link and link it looks as though Jane's power is stronger. Crutiatus' pain is described as worse than "one thousand white-hot knives, boring into the skin." It can also be dodged, blocked 由 a solid object and if 你 happen to be a strong willed wizard/witch then 你 can resist the pain until the spell is lifted. Jane's power is instantaneous and the pain is the same as being burnt alive. Think about it, not hot knives boring into skin, but your whole body being burnt alive ie your skin, your insides etc. It can't be deflected, resisted (unless you're Bella 或者 within her protection area) 或者 dodged and it does not need to be cast.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
next question »