In Round 1, Elsa was tied for elimination but in Round 2, she lost to Merida. That being said, only 1 of the comments supported this so far while Elsa as the runner up had 2 comments supporting her elimination so far. So to be fair, I have posted this tie-breaker just to be sure. :)

don't think she was selfless till she realized her mistake by the end whereas Elsa was selfless that she stayed away from her family to keep them away from harm.

Elsa did care more...and spent more time displaying her fears. Merida just kept badgering her mother about her thoughts on the marriage--- even after it was totally obvious that her mother was doubled over in pain.

^ I agree with both comments above.