迪士尼公主
What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)
迪士尼公主 Sometimes Flynn/Rapunzel's characters are criticized for being unoriginal. Do 你 agree that one of them/both are unoriginal?
55 fans picked: |
No
|
|||
Yes, but it doesn't bug me
|
|||
Yea, it annoys me
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
Although Rapunzel is a mashup of all the other princesses, which ends up making her an original entity to me. IDK, might change my vote . . .
Rapunzel is unoriginal, plain and simple. She's great, but there's nothing new about her, nothing she does, no quality she has, that another princess doesn't have/do.
Flynn is a little harder to explain. First his dream of wanting a lot of money is obviously not original, Naveen had the same aspirations, and the way he gave it up for Rapunzel is the same as Naveen. His actual personality/sense of humor....is maybe original, but very expected. When I watched the movie, I liked it, but I wasn't like wow! groundbreaking! he had a very predictable personaity.
As for it annoying me....yes, a little, but I still like both of their characters. I'm not annoyed by them as characters, more annoyed at just the fact that disney just can't be as original as they used to.
For example, Jasmine's starting point is essentially Ariel's. Privileged but unsatisfied, no mother, loving father whose inability to understand what his daughter wants from life causes fights, runs away, her romance is a mix of love at first sight and getting to know each other, divides fans on whether she's spoilt or just fairly fighting for what she wants from life, and there are more similarities too but I don't consider Jasmine unoriginal, and my opinion of her is different to my opinion of Ariel. I see similarities with previous stories in almost all the Disney princess movies if I look for it.
When you break their traits into separate chunks Rapunzel and Flynn share a lot with previous characters, but for my enjoyment at least, the way those separate characteristics combined was into characters I found fresh enough to enjoy a lot. I see where those who disagree are coming from though, but it wasn't a problem for me :)
Sure, there are small traits that other characters have, but they're too small to really matter.
There are also things she does that in my opinion none of the others would (things like blackmailing a stranger into what she thinks will be a very dangerous journey so she can fulfill a minor wish, being the only 'trapped' princess to not just be happy when free and actually suffer emotionally from it)
I don't think they all did bring any specific new thing anyway. Using Jasmine again as an example, I don't personally find any of her individual traits or basic plot points unique, only what they combine to make is unique in my opinion.
Again, I do get the point of those who disagree though, this is just how I see it :)
We're not saying that she isn't a new character, we're saying that there was nothing slightly groundbreaking about her. Each of the other princesses brought something new to the table.
登录或者加入潮流粉丝俱乐部来发表你的评论