回答这一问题

迪士尼公主 问题

Sleeping Beauty and Maleficent: Old vs New

I'm 写作 an 文章 comparing the original 迪士尼 Princess 电影院 and their remakes and I would like to know everyone's thoughts about both 电影院 and which they prefer; original 或者 remake.

Just answer the following with "original" 或者 "remake". 你 can either just say one of those two words 或者 你 can answer and give a reason.

最喜爱的 Aurora

最喜爱的 Maleficent

最喜爱的 Good 精灵

最喜爱的 King Stefan

最喜爱的 Prince Phillip

最喜爱的 Crow

最喜爱的 Once Upon a Dream

最喜爱的 Plot

最喜爱的 Curse

最喜爱的 Prince and Princess meeting

最喜爱的 Spinning Wheel scene

最喜爱的 Dragon

最喜爱的 True Love's Kiss



The deadline will be June 21!
 BB2010 posted 一年多以前
next question »

迪士尼公主 答案

sunnyfields said:
最喜爱的 Aurora: Original

最喜爱的 Maleficent: Original (a true villain)

最喜爱的 Good Fairies: Original (not careless)

最喜爱的 King Stefan: Original (not evil)

最喜爱的 Prince Phillip: Original (actually saved Aurora)

最喜爱的 Crow: Original (I prefer him as a crow, not human)

最喜爱的 Once Upon a Dream: Remake (I like the creepy sound, but I like both versions)

最喜爱的 Plot: Original

最喜爱的 Curse: Original

最喜爱的 Prince and Princess meeting: Original (so romantic with their dance in the woods)

最喜爱的 Spinning Wheel scene: Original (more scary)

最喜爱的 Dragon: Original (more memorable)

最喜爱的 True Love's Kiss: Original (it actually worked with the prince, and I like that better)

select as best answer
 最喜爱的 Aurora: Original 最喜爱的 Maleficent: Original (a true villain) 最喜爱的 Good Fairies: Original (not careless) 最喜爱的 King Stefan: Original (not evil) 最喜爱的 Prince Phillip: Original (actually saved Aurora) 最喜爱的 Crow: Original (I prefer him as a crow, not human) 最喜爱的 Once Upon a Dream: Remake (I like the creepy sound, but I like both versions) 最喜爱的 Plot: Original 最喜爱的 Curse: Original 最喜爱的 Prince and Princess meeting: Original (so romantic with their dance in the woods) 最喜爱的 Spinning Wheel scene: Original (more scary) 最喜爱的 Dragon: Original (more memorable) 最喜爱的 True Love's Kiss: Original (it actually worked with the prince, and I like that better)
posted 一年多以前 
HoltNLucy4Ever said:
最喜爱的 Aurora: Original
最喜爱的 Maleficent: Original
最喜爱的 Good Faries: Original
最喜爱的 King Stefan: Original
最喜爱的 Prince Phillip: Original
最喜爱的 Crow: Original
最喜爱的 Once Upon A Dream: Original
最喜爱的 Plot: Original
最喜爱的 Curse: Original
最喜爱的 Prince and Princess meeting: Original
最喜爱的 Spinning Wheel scene: Original
最喜爱的 Dragon: Original
最喜爱的 True Love's Kiss: Original

select as best answer
 最喜爱的 Aurora: Original 最喜爱的 Maleficent: Original 最喜爱的 Good Faries: Original 最喜爱的 King Stefan: Original 最喜爱的 Prince Phillip: Original 最喜爱的 Crow: Original 最喜爱的 Once Upon A Dream: Original 最喜爱的 Plot: Original 最喜爱的 Curse: Original 最喜爱的 Prince and Princess meeting: Original 最喜爱的 Spinning Wheel scene: Original 最喜爱的 Dragon: Original 最喜爱的 True Love's Kiss: Original
posted 一年多以前 
deedragongirl said:
Original: Not saying that Elle Fanning's 表演 is bad, but she seems quite stiff at some of the movie.

Original: She is THE MISTRESS OF ALL EVIL!!!

Original: They're 更多 practical than their remake counterparts!

Original: Why the evilness in the remake?

Original: He has less screen time in the remake!

Original: He's loyal

Original: DUH! Because it's memorable!

Original: The plot is 更多 straightforward.

Original: The scene speaks out for itself!

Original: 更多 chemistry!

Original: The 音乐 says it all, thank 你 Tchaikovsky.

Original: The 音乐 and the scene project itself.

Orignal: Once again, the music.

Call me bias, but hey!
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
what did 你 think of the plot?
BB2010 posted 一年多以前
*
Added already ;)
deedragongirl posted 一年多以前
magicworld_88 said:
最喜爱的 aurora : original
最喜爱的 maleficent : original the true maleficent the one who is suppose To be the mistress of all evil
最喜爱的 精灵 : original
最喜爱的 king stephan : original
最喜爱的 prince phillip : original
最喜爱的 乌鸦 : original
最喜爱的 once upon a dream : original but i like Lana del rey version
最喜爱的 plot : original
最喜爱的 curse : original of course ! The curse is very important in the fairy tale . The curse is the same in All sleeping beauty's adaptations the original from perrault, brother grimm version , 迪士尼 , 图书 for kids , 电影院 adaptations. Changing the curse of sleeping beauty is for me just like if we decide That ariel had to give the trident instead of her voice , 灰姑娘 迷失 Two glass slipper , 阿拉丁 only have Two wish and rapunzel doesnt live any longer in a tower but a house. In the movie maleficent, she doesnt want aurora to be dead anymore , they Forgot about the last fairy's gift and throw out of the Windows the mentions of " 100 years of slumber" and apparently they did that because they needed to 显示 king stephan beg maleficent. So yeah the original i dont like how they treat the original fairy tale in maleficent.
最喜爱的 prince and princess meeting : original in the animated their meeting is strange but still cute and romantic. In maleficent i just find the scene so embarassing.
最喜爱的 spinning wheel scene : original 更多 scary
最喜爱的 dragon : the one in maleficent looks good but original !
最喜爱的 true 爱情 吻乐队(Kiss) : original !

select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
PrincessAyeka12 said:
最喜爱的 Aurora - Original

最喜爱的 Maleficent - Original

最喜爱的 Good 精灵 - Original

最喜爱的 King Stefan - Original

最喜爱的 Prince Phillip - Original

最喜爱的 乌鸦 - Original

最喜爱的 Once Upon a Dream - Original

最喜爱的 Plot - Original

最喜爱的 Curse - Original

最喜爱的 Prince and Princess meeting - Original

最喜爱的 Spinning Wheel scene - Original

最喜爱的 Dragon - Original

最喜爱的 True Love's 吻乐队(Kiss) - Original
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
Swanpride said:
The original is superior in every aspect. I can't express enough how much I 爱情 it - the animation, the bad-ass characters, the 音乐 - and how much I hate the remake. Especially what they did to the fairies. And that they 偷了 the transformation from Maleficent.
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
*
Right! This was not even a moderately close faithful adaptation. Phillip's 吻乐队(Kiss) didn't work, the 精灵 are seen as incompetent and stupid, the king was turned evil, and so many 更多 things that make me want to forget that this was even a live action remake. Cinderella, Aladdin, and Beauty and the Beast were handled much better and with 更多 respect to the 来源 material.
sunnyfields posted 一年多以前
*
I haven't seen Aladdin, but so far the only remake I liked was Jungle Book and that was because they did something new which could have stood on its own without the unnecessary reference to the animated movie. It's not that they did something different whcih bothers me about Maleficent, it is that the sh... all over the original while doing it. The 精灵 are just insulting.
Swanpride posted 一年多以前
KataraLover said:
最喜爱的 Aurora: Remake
最喜爱的 Maleficent: Original
最喜爱的 Good Fairies: Original
最喜爱的 King Stefan: Original
最喜爱的 Prince Phillip: Original
最喜爱的 Crow: Original
最喜爱的 Once Upon a Dream: Original
最喜爱的 Plot: Original
最喜爱的 Curse: Original
最喜爱的 Prince and Princess meeting: Original
最喜爱的 Spinning Wheel scene: Original
最喜爱的 Dragon: Original
最喜爱的 True Love's Kiss: Original
select as best answer
posted 一年多以前 
next question »