Here's some background, if it helps:
I was baptized when I was a baby, made Communion in second grade (under threat of not going on to 3rd grade). About a month ago, my mother, father, and I were chatting about my wedding. I said I was going to have a Pagan wedding, since I am Pagan. My mother and father were instantly up in arms, saying that I was going to have a Christian wedding, since I was a Christian.

I politely informed them (again, but that's completely beside the point) that, no, I was not, and it didn't make sense for me to have a Christian wedding. My mother said "yes, you are. You were baptized. You're a Christian."

It made me curious if other Catholic/Christians felt the same way.

no i don't really think so but i'm not too sure on it because if you have a different belief and you're of a different religion then no

You are what you believe. You can say all you want a rock is a tree but its not. Some people just can't accept it when someone in their family, especially a child of theirs, has a different faith than them. Ultimately it's your wedding and you should do what you want :)